Tom McHale [not shown] writes [via ammoland.com]: Believe it or not, there was a time that shooters went into full-scale revolt about the idea of putting scopes on rifles. You’d hear arguments like “Why would I want to put something that will just break on my rifle? Iron sights will always work!” Fast forward some decades and similar arguments popped up like Whack-a-Moles about the ridiculous idea of putting red dot optics on fighting rifles.
The arguments were similar, just updated for the times. Whether the complaints were about potential reliability problems or more along the lines of “The batteries are going to run out just when you need them most,” there was plenty of resistance to a new way of doing things.
Now, when you drove around places like Parris Island, you’ll see rifles neatly stacked all equipped with optics, even for basic training. While most people feel good having backup iron sights, even the perceived necessity of those is diminishing.
I’ll never argue against the wisdom of having a backup, but in civilian usage scenarios, it’s a rare thing indeed for a quality optic to fail.
The one sure thing about new self defense gun optics technology is that it plows relentlessly forward and over time, new inventions that many initially consider gimmicks gain reliability and trust.
I think the next example case of new gear becoming mainstream is the idea of sticking optical sights on defensive handguns. It’s not a new concept – competitors have been using red dot sights on pistols for quite some time. But risking failure of an electronic piece of gear on a competitive stage carries a lot less downside than a similar failure when fighting for your life. Most steel and paper targets don’t shoot back.
I’ve been tinkering with optics on handguns for a few months now, and as I write this, I’m out in the Nevada desert learning some new techniques with Springfield Armory’s Rob Leatham and the knowledgeable folks from Apex Expert Solutions. We’ve been shooting the new Springfield Armory XD(M) OSP pistol equipped with Trijicon RMR sights.
During Rob’s introduction to the class, he explained that there are two primary benefits to using optical sights on a self defense handgun:
First, everything is in the same focal plane – target and the sighting dot. Look at your target and the dot will appear superimposed on it. There is no need for your eye to shift focus to and from the front sight, rear sight, and target.
From a purely common sense perspective, this is a good thing. Not only does your brain save time avoiding all that focus point switching, your noggin tends to focus on threats naturally anyway. Why not embrace that natural tendency with the equipment we use?
Second, red dot sights largely eliminate the ill effects of less than perfect vision. If you’ve got aging eyes and require a little lens correction to see a crisp front sight, there’s a good chance that you won’t have that problem with a red dot optic. As Rob Leatham says, “an optical sight gives you years.”
I think there’s another benefit. A red dot is really helpful, because it’s really visible, in low light conditions. Make no mistake, it won’t help you identify a target in the dark, but it will help you aim in less than ideal light conditions.
On the flip side, there are certain drawbacks to consider.
Self Defense Gun Optics – Finding the Dot
To address the giant Harambe in the room first, there’s the issue of finding the dot. Under time or violent encounter stress, you may raise the gun only to see an empty window. At exactly the moment you need to shoot quickly you might be more occupied with figuring out how to aim.
I have to wonder if this challenge is somehow analogous to early rifle scope users learning how to cheek weld consistently to gain the correct eye placement relative to the scope. We’ll come back to this later . . .
On a related point, some people lose the dot during recoil. Most of the time, the reason for this is that the muzzle ends up pointing slightly down after the shot. As Rob explained, that’s almost always a result of one of two things: overcompensation against recoil or a natural tendency to lower the gun to see where you shot went.
Self-Defense Gun Optics Reliability
Next up is the reliability concern. Unless you’re able to set up a co-witness configuration where you still have a clear view of iron sights, then an equipment breakage or malfunction can make your life somewhat difficult.
When new technology enters from stage left it can be finicky and fragile in the early years. Until gear has been through not only rigorous testing but also real word use by thousands of users, it’s probably a good idea not to trust it with your life.
At this point in optical sight history, we have a lot of real world experience. Optics are tough and have proven their ability to stand up to not only a steady diet of punishing recoil but knocks and dings.
The bottom line is that if you buy quality gear, you’re going to have to try really hard to break it, especially under normal concealed carry or home defense usage scenarios.
Self Defense Gun Optics Batteries
Knowing that someone is going to bring up the battery issue, let’s talk about that for a second. Yes, the batteries might go dead. On the other hand, your car can also go dead at any moment by running out of gas. We’re all responsible enough to manage to keep our cars full of fuel, so I tend to believe we can also take responsibility for changing batteries in an optical sight on a regular basis.
Rather than waiting to find out that your optic is dead, how about just changing batteries out on a recurring schedule? After all, we’re responsible enough to carry a lethal weapon, so I don’t think it’s too much to ask to swap batteries every few months.
I like Aimpoint optics on my AR-15 rifles because you just leave them on and the batteries run for 75 percent of forever. Even still, I have a calendar reminder set up on my phone reminding me to swap batteries once a year. Do I worry about my batteries failing? Nope, not at all. That’s because I act like a big boy and take responsibility for keeping the batteries fresh.
Here are a few tips offered by up Rob Leatham.
Practice, practice, practice. Raising an iron sight equipped pistol into the perfect firing position from a draw where the front and rear sights are aligned with each other, and the target requires practice and repetition – lots of it. The same thing applies when using a red dot sight with your handgun.
When sitting at home (using all proper and safe dry fire procedures) practice drawing your gun to a target. Do it slow and repeat – lots and lots of times. A trick is to try to forget about the dot. Strangely enough, many of us tend to get so wrapped up looking for the dot that we can’t find it. I
f you raise your gun as normal, looking for the front sight, the dot will simply appear. The proper aim and fire position of the gun is identical whether you’re using an optic or iron sights, so don’t make it harder than it has to be. I think you’ll find as you practice that the dot will start to magically appear on your target very quickly.
The other issues with self defense gun optics that may require some technique refinement is dealing with recoil. Whatever sights you’re using, iron or optics, your gun should end the recoil cycle pointed right back at the target, not above or below.
If your muzzle tends to dip after each shot, that’s something you need to fix whether you’re using irons or the fancy electronic stuff. Grab that gun tight. Let it recoil, but don’t try to force it back down. With a solid grip and a recognition that recoil will happen, focus on just allowing the gun to settle back into its starting position.
It might be hard to spot a muzzle dip problem so you can have a range buddy watch from the side to see how you’re doing. Of course, if you already have an optic on your gun, then you’ll know you messed up if the dot is no longer visible.
Time will tell, but I’d bet that self defense gun optics will become more and more common on carry guns. In my own experimentation, I find I can shoot more precisely faster when using an optic.
For extreme close range shots, I’m not really using a dot or iron sights anyway, but rather pointing over the slide, so I haven’t experienced a drawback there. And on longer ranges, it’s been all upside so far.
Tom McHale is the author of the Insanely Practical Guides book series that guides new and experienced shooters alike in a fun, approachable, and practical way. His books are available in print and eBook format on Amazon. You can also find him on Google+, Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest.
Bushnell trs 25 is inexpensive, holds zero, lightweight and compact. No problems so far used mostly on my ruger mark 3.
That’s a bit big for the average carry pistol. I have one of those on my AR.
The Vortex Spitfire, with the prism etched reticle, will work on or off. No need for a BUIS. Probably too big for a handgun though.
I have always ignored the standard instruction to focus on the front sight. I shoot pistol while focused on the target, letting the sights go blurry. Both reasons were addressed above:
a) When faced with a deadly threat, our instincts will kick in and we will focus on the threat anyway, so we might as well train that way.
b) At my age, I require reading glasses to focus at arm’s length. And I’m pretty sure they won’t be on my face when a threat presents itself.
So, I train like I intend to fight. And this does limit my accuracy potential, but still allows for minute-of-bad-guy precision inside of 15 yards or so. It’s unlikely I’ll need to engage a target further away than that in a DGU.
While I would have no problem using electronic optics on a defensive pistol, their profile limits their use to OWB holsters. IWB and pocket carry would be impractical.
No kidding. Exactly. Point and shoot. Self defense distances don’t require rocket science. Don’t overthink it.
Sheesh, some of you guys would put a red dot on your peckers.
Now that’s just silly. Green laser is best for that application… unless you can actually get a cheek weld, but at that point I think you could do whatever you want and nobody could really question you.
Someone, somewhere, is going to wind up racking the slide with one of these things at some point during a one-handed reload.
I’d be interested in knowing if and how that affects point of aim (obviously for the slide-mounted optic, not a frame mounted one).
If it is a good quality optic and it is screwed down properly it should not affect poi at pistol distances.
The chances of actually needing a “one handed reload” and coincidentally having a red dot on one’s pistol are exactly zero.
My money is on No.
The quality ones are solid 7075 Aluminum, and while the moment arm is longer than a rear sight, I’ve never heard of someone ripping their rear sight off doing one-handed manipulation.
But time will tell.. as with Red-Dot AR15s, the early adopters will help refine the technology to the point of becoming desirable in the mainstream market.
I have one pistol with a red dot but its a raced out competition pistol not a defensive pistol.
If it were easier to mount one I’d likely have more but the current climate of milling the slide or shady adapters turns me off.
A question I’ve had for a while about red dots on EDC guns is do you just keep them on the whole time, or are there some models that automatically turn on with movement, or do you have to flip the sights on after you draw?
If you keep them on the whole time, how long do the batteries last?
I’ve got a Deltapoint Pro on a 17L. I mounted it using the Leupold rear sight dovetail kit for Glocks. With a high (0.625″) front sight from Dawson Precision it co-witnesses pretty well for my purposes using the DP Pro’s adjustable rear iron sight. The whole setup was easy enough to install myself and hasn’t given me any problems and didn’t require a milled slide. But, that front sight is pretty darn high and this is not meant to be a carry piece.
I like co-witnessing the irons with the dot as it seemed to help my learning curve for using/acquiring the dot. Plus, I suppose it gives you a backup if the sight dies on you.
Whack-A-Mole is what I think of when Iry to shut down the ad at the bottom of this page.
you have to sneak up on it from the right side. over and over…
I really like red dot sights, I’ve used them on gaming pistols for years. My only problem with them is they make them too big. You don’t need a window the size of silver dollar, it could just be a few millimeters taller than iron sights (and no wider than the slide).
Personally I perfer laser grips to the red dot. More compact, holster friendly, better at night. The laser also has it’s own imtimitdation factor.
At handgun distances, it is hard to argue with that. Whatever merits red dots may have on handguns, those same merits are much greater on longer range guns.
I wouldn’t put much weight on “intimidation.” What you gain in intimidation, you may well lose right back in giving away your position, aim and intent. And I’m not convinced non cops have much business intimidating others with a handgun anyway, believing civilians shouldn’t draw unless they have committed to fire. Of course, I’m just applying my own particular personal biases to weighing of factors here.
made the jump and now run a glock 19 with RMR. I was sceptical at first but the benefits are real. Groups sizes shrunk immediately, can focus entirely on the target. Very forgiving on aging eyes. Once you get the draw strike down the dot naturally appears on the target, no need to hunt for it. An unexpected benefit is the feedback you get during dry fire practice. If you snatch the trigger the dot will let you know immediately.
Why do these guys insist on ignoring the best way to set this up and eliminate the biggest complaint, e.g. CO-WITNESS THE SIGHTS! It makes acquiring the dot natural and easy and it eliminates concerns about the battery. Come on, guys!
I already have CrimsonTrace lasergrips on my defensive handguns
They work great, even in bright sunlight at 10 yards
So why use these big things on top of my gun?
Older eyes see red dots as a comma or blur
Laser is always a spot
Laser allows unorthodox shooting
positions . Gun and eyes don’t need to be lined up like a red dot
You can be looking under the bed and exposing only your hand and shooting over the bed
Laser seems better for short handgun distances
Red dot is better for longer ranges
laser is visible over self defense distances