Over the past four decades, most American states chose to let everyday citizens carry concealed weapons. Indeed, about half of states no longer even require a permit to pack heat.
New York took a different path — but is being dragged into a more lenient gun-carrying regime by the courts. Exactly how far it will be dragged is an open question. But there are two reasons for New Yorkers not to panic.
First, while parts of the state’s strict new law will likely be struck down, New York will retain ample discretion to make permits hard to get — including fees, training requirements and restrictions on where guns may be carried. And second, even in states that liberalized their gun-carrying laws with gusto, the effects on crime are small enough that, despite decades of research, they remain hard to measure reliably. …
New York doesn’t have to love being forced into a right-to-carry policy, but there is also no reason to panic. When the court struggles reach their end, the state will retain plenty of discretion to make legal gun-carrying difficult — even for those with clean records.
— Robert VerBruggen in The Sky Won’t Fall if More New Yorkers Carry Guns