Question of the Day: How Does Shannon Watts Explain Star Wars to Her Kids?

Reader ML writes

By now, millions have watched the new trailer for the next cash cow from Hollywood…myself included…and most are excited for the new Star Wars story. This made me ponder the following question: how can the anti-gun crowd explain to their kids why the Jedi FIGHT evil with swords, when they are opposed to doing the same in real life? If the good guys fly spaceships with guns, use lightsabers and blasters to defeat bad guys with guns, cooler lightsabers and blasters, why the double standard?

Are all fans of Star Wars are just gun-nutz? Is the thought of picking up a (lightsaber) gun for protection too scary to comprehend? Or are they really just whimps?


  1. avatar NikcaP says:

    All they say is its pretend… that’s not how the “real world” works.

    1. avatar General Zod says:

      …and then they turn around and support legislation to require the kind of Hollywood magic biometric ID system like the one James Bond had in his gun…

  2. avatar younggun21 says:

    Good point. But that goes for pretty much all of hollywood. Find an action movie where there isn’t a cop or a civilian using a gun or some type of weapon to defend themselves, those they love, or innocent people. Yet, the entirety of hollywood is rabidly anti self defense. Makes you wonder why its such a good selling point?

    1. avatar Sian says:

      More telling and to the point though, find a movie where a civilian, without military, police, or assassin training, uses a firearm in self-defense and is portrayed in a positive light.

      They are few.

      It simply reinforces their assertion that ‘only the government and military are responsible enough to be armed’, even when said government is portrayed as the enemy.

      1. avatar Benny the Jew says:

        In episodes 4-6, the Rebellion was tantamount to an irregular militia battling a tyrannical government, the Empire.

  3. avatar CRF says:

    “But, but, but, bad people don’t exist in the real world. It can’t happen to me. The police are always there.”

    1. avatar dh34 says:

      “Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid.”

      1. avatar Michael says:

        I find your lack of faith disturbing

        1. avatar Chris T from KY says:

          Darn the best lines have been taken.

    2. avatar Cliff H says:

      But that was a galaxy far, far away and a long time ago. We’re much more socially evolved here. (/sarc)

    3. avatar William says:

      She is altering reality. Pray she does not alter it any further.

      1. avatar RenderMan says:

        This reality is getting worse all the time.

  4. avatar Xanthro says:

    It’s because they think current society is more enlightened and you don’t have to fight evil. Evil can be reasoned with and is subject to “rational” arguments.
    To them, the rebels wouldn’t have to use lightsabers or other weapons, they would just talk to the Emperor or the Sith and the latter would come to an understanding and everything would be fine.

    1. avatar younggun21 says:

      Yup. To them there is nothing in this world that can’t be run away from or dealt with the electoral process. These were the loyalists in 1776.

    2. avatar Bob Wall says:

      Everyone just sing along, it’s all good…

  5. avatar Bob Wall says:

    Shannon Watts – Magna cun laude from the Jar-Jar Binks school of philosophy, with a minor in (ir)rationality.

  6. avatar Grindstone says:

    Is the thought of picking up a (lightsaber) gun for protection too scary to comprehend?

    Where does one acquire this… “lightsaber gun”…? I’m asking for a friend…

    1. avatar dh34 says:

      Me too…for a friend also.

      1. avatar Mud says:

        Let’s meet up at the next gun show (lightsaber show?). I have a trunk full of them.

        1. avatar dh34 says:

          These aren’t the Remington ones that were recalled awhile back are they? Something about a safety issue?

    2. avatar LarryinTX says:

      Unfortunately, mine are all in the lake.

    3. avatar Removed_californian says:

      In the newest animated Star Wars story, there is this Palawan named Ezra, he uses a lightsaber that is also a blaster. Too lazy to link.

  7. avatar Fred says:

    It’s because all that happened a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.

    Also, Jedi are trained all their lives to use lightsabers, soldiers are trained, and the rebellion? That was just a misunderstanding over semantic points. So if you are trained all your life, sanctioned by society, and lived a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away you too can have weapons.

    1. avatar LarryinTX says:

      However, only fictional weapons.

  8. avatar Chip Bennett says:

    If you hadn’t noticed before, in the Star Wars universe, it is only the Sith (evil) who believe in black-and-white principles of right and wrong (“Only a Sith deals in absolutes.”). Those concepts are mutable for the (good) Jedi, the mantra of whom was:

    There is no emotion, there is peace.
    There is no ignorance, there is knowledge.
    There is no passion, there is serenity.
    There is no chaos, there is harmony.
    There is no death, there is the Force.

    Oh, and the Jedi were basically self-appointed LEO.

    So, even allowing that Star Wars isn’t simply “explained” by it being a work of fiction, it would be easy enough to fit Star Wars concepts into a civilian disarmament point of view.

    1. avatar Cliff H says:

      “Only a Sith deals in absolutes.”

      “Do, or do not, there is no try.” – Yoda

      Sounds like an absolute to me.

    2. avatar Five says:

      I think the Sith (Dark Side) and the Empire as Lucas originally intended was an analog for the USA during the Vietnam war and the Rebellion the Vietcong (strange that Lucas left out the political mass-killings and genocides perpetrated by North Vietnam/Rebellion).

      Anyhow, the more recent interpretations of the Sith I’ve seen make their story a good allegory to the Progressive movement. (Wish I could find some of the links for references…)

    3. avatar tdiinva (now in Wisconsin) says:

      They are Samurai.

  9. avatar dh34 says:

    Alderaan was a peaceful planet, it supposedly had no weapons. Last time I checked the Empire used eminent domain to clear a hyperspace turnpike through it.

    1. avatar DetroitMan says:

      This comment wins the thread. Now I have to clean the coffee off of my monitor…

    2. avatar Reggie says:

      The Star Wars humor is strong with this one.

    3. avatar schernobyl says:

      That’s the plot to hitchhikers guide to the galaxy

      1. avatar dh34 says:

        Yes it was. But there’s no need for an off ramp at Alderaan either.

    4. avatar Juanito ''Johnnie'' Ibañez says:

      Actually, DH, that was “hyperspace bypass…” 🙂

  10. avatar dh34 says:

    And while we’re on the subject, no civilian really needs a star freighter that can do the Kessel Run in 12 parsecs…or can out run Imperial starships, not just local bulk cruisers, but the big Corellian ships.

  11. avatar Another Robert says:

    Not to be a wet blanket, but Shannon Watts’ “kids” are pretty much all grown up or in the adolescent stage. They don’t need “explaining” like this, and they don’t need Shannon to “stay at home” with them–which she doesn’t, in fact.

    1. avatar dh34 says:

      So what you’re saying is Shannon’s story, like Star Wars is fiction?

      The difference being one is entertaining and the other is just a story made up in someone mind.

  12. avatar Dunebuggy says:

    The Empire are the Leftist. They explain it this as such. If we don’t get those bad rebels out of our country this could happen to us.
    And this is not a Star Wars movie this is a Disney bastardization of what was once a great story.

    1. avatar Hoothoot says:

      So Disney was involved in the prequels, too? Guess that would explain the CG atrocity with the initials J.J.B…

      1. avatar CarlosT says:

        Nope, that was all on Lucas and Lucasfilm.

  13. avatar Former Water Walker says:

    So how does the midget billionaire Bloomie(Shannon’s sugar-daddy) rationalize arming Israel but f##king Americans? Star Wars is pure fantasy so there is no disconnect(Dirk where R U?)…

    1. avatar dh34 says:

      Bloomberg is more Dark Helmet than Darth Vadar.

      1. avatar Julio says:

        Dirk might say “I bet she gives great helmet!”

        1. avatar Geoff PR says:

          Dirk believes proper training is key…

          (sound of bullwhip *crack*)

  14. avatar dlj95118 says:

    “…it’s a stooooory! It’s not real! It’s just a stooooooooory!”

    1. avatar Adub says:

      And it is neverending…

  15. avatar jwm says:

    We don’t care how anti gun mommies explain it to the kids. The kids see good guys with guns and sabers beating up the bad guys. It’s a life lesson parents can only influence if they totally isolate their kids in the basement and allow them no outside contact.

    We are no longer a rural, frontier nation but guns sell like hotcakes. Why? Kids are bombarded by video games and other influnces and they say, “I don’t want to be a victim.” They see a violent world streamed into their homes 24/7 and they say, “I’m not letting that happen to me”

    We need a TTAG poll. How many first time gun buyers under the age of 40 come from families that are urban or suburban and never had guns in the home? They’re the first in their families to gun up?

    1. avatar schernobyl says:

      Raises hand.

      For my side, wife’s side taught me to shoot

    2. avatar Juanito ''Johnnie'' Ibañez says:

      “We are no longer a rural, frontier nation but guns sell like hotcakes. Why?”

      Because today is “wilder” than the so-called “Wild West” of yesteryear…

    3. avatar Raoul Duke says:

      Another raised hand here.

      Grew up in the suburbs and I had to get into guns on my own since no one around me had them, well except for my neighbor who showed me his Colt 1911 once but that was my only exposure to a real firearm until I decided at 18 to get a rifle for myself.

  16. avatar neiowa says:

    I’d be impressed if that idiot Lucas advanced his battlefield tactics past 1915. Has Lucas made a movie in the last 30years that wasn’t total crap?

  17. avatar Noishkel says:

    Feh. Watt’s is just fine with this movie. People like that just don’t have the mental capacity for that kind of deep thought.

  18. avatar Ralph says:

    Shannon would say: “The daddy uses his light saber to put a seed into the mommy. Then the mommy has a baby. Then the mommy dumps daddy for another daddy with more money. Then the mommy hooks up with a miniature billionaire named Darth Bloomberg whose light saber stopped working long ago and far away. The end.”

    1. avatar Adub says:

      It’s funny how often that works out. Or doesn’t.

      My ex is dating a stocker at Wal-Mart, while I, as a tax attorney, have a wider variety of options half her age. And not all of them are hookers. 😉

  19. avatar schernobyl says:

    Luke a hould have stayed a farmer. Han was a self professed criminal. Hence why he had a modified blaster. Leia was an terrorist insurrectionist who got around. The empire didn’t do bad things until Leia stole from the state.

    That’s how Shannon explains things. Root for the empire

  20. avatar pres stone says:

    wow logic fail. a gun is not a sword. end of lesson.

    1. avatar Sian says:

      High-powered Armor Piercing Assault Laser Swords never need reloading and can cut through Stormtrooper armor like it wasn’t even there. One was even used to take out a tank! We can’t let powerful murderweapons like these, built by lasersexual cultist fanatics and only good for slaughtering as many people as possible, fall into the hands of rebel scum! We only want peace and order in the galaxy, for the children! #lightsabersense

      1. avatar dh34 says:


  21. avatar Big Jim says:

    Who gives a crap what Shannon watts does thinks or explains to her kids They’re probably a bunch of mental midgets just like mom! The woman only cares about being in front of a camera I’ve caught footage of her actually running to get in front of a camera just because it was there and they were doing a film piece the media was She’s another anti gun Pro liberal aggressive Liar Just like President Obama And Hillary Clinton when are we going to see these people get prosecuted for violating the Constitution and the laws that are set in place to keep these people from doing these things and they just keep doing them and nobody cares I don’t get that if it was me or you and we would do committing federal crimes we’d be imprisoned faster than you could say ouch.

  22. avatar Gman says:

    “How Does Shannon Watts Explain Star Wars to Her Kids?”

    With lies and obfuscation of course.

    1. avatar dh34 says:

      “Do you think I give crap about guns or light sabers or lasers or any of that stuff? It’s just Mommy’s job. Now put this shirt on and look sad…”

  23. avatar Narcoossee says:

    So, on a related note, here’s something to ponder: How is it that gun-hatin’ Chicago worked so darn hard to land what’s essentially the “Star Wars Museum”? I’d think that all that self-defense and armed rabble rousing as portrayed in the Star Wars story line would be anathema to them.

    1. avatar dh34 says:

      If it hadn’t been for the loose blaster laws on the surrounding planets, Chicagoraan would be a much safer place.

    2. avatar IL-annoyed says:

      Lucas did a lot of work for Columbia College (wife attended that school) in chicago… might be part of the reason

  24. avatar Bill says:

    How I will explain it to mine someday:

    “Han shot first”

    1. avatar schernobyl says:

      Greedo shot first, Han shot in self defense

      1. avatar Jeff O says:

        Is this is one of those “Nineteen Eighty-Four” Memory Holes I’ve heard so much about?

        Double-Plus Good!

      2. avatar Juanito ''Johnnie'' Ibañez says:

        schernobyl wrote on October 21, 2015 at 13:36 hours:

        “Greedo shot first, Han shot in self defense”

        That’s in the later, ‘Director’s Cut’, version: not in the original 1977 release.

        1. avatar Removed_californian says:

          That’s part of the joke. Lucas has always asserted that greedo shot first even though when the rough script for ANH was recovered it clearly states: “Han shoots greedo.”

          Lucas essentially tried to rewrite history. Lol Lucas.

        2. avatar dh34 says:

          Greedo was misunderstood. Yeah he had a troubled past, but his dad abandoned his family right before he hatched, and he was raised by a single mom who did the best she could. He had just started taking community college classes and was really turning his life around.


  25. avatar JimM says:

    It would give her an opportunity to explain safe gun handling. In the first episode Obe Wan hands Luke a pistol. Luke accepts it and immediately holds it with his finger on the trigger and looks down the barrel. Did anyone else notice?

    1. avatar Sian says:

      You may have your facts a little shuffled up there.

    2. avatar Henry says:

      First she’d had to understand safe gun handling. Her idea of “gun safety” is “ban guns.”

  26. avatar Gatorgrabber says:

    I’m afraid hypocrisy is lost on that crowd. They live in make-believe worlds…far, far away!

  27. avatar GunGeek says:

    The old bio on Moms Demand Action (which I mistakenly thought was a porn site), her youngest is 14 – so he’s now 16 or thereabouts. I’d expect she has bigger problems than explaining Star Wars plot points.

    And of course, teenagers always listen to their parents. He’s probably more receptive to enrolling in a NRA youth shooting program.

  28. avatar Southern Cross says:

    In the Star Wsrs extended universe the Rebellion/New Republic asks Lando to help them in a special operation with his “special talents”, because General Solo is unavailable.

    Commenting on the special talents, Lando says “We are crooks”.

    Better to have crooks than a self-imposed theocratic religious group whose heads are so full of nerf wool it is often child’s play to pull it over their eyes.

  29. avatar Alejandro says:

    I’m actually pretty damn hype for the new movies. The instant I saw they went back to using (some) real gun parts for the props again I was excited. After they’re out, I might be trying to make a shiny new tactical sterling/E-11

  30. avatar Publius says:

    She explains it the way all liberals do – the Empire is the benevolent government trying to keep people safe and keep society clean and orderly, while the terrorist Rebels want to destroy society and hurt people.

    I can’t be the only one who notices that, with the exception of a very few political films, the bad guys are ALWAYS liberals. The bad guys always want complete control. They always believe that “society” is more important than individuals or freedom. They always believe that hurting people for “the greater good” is justified. It just blows my mind that almost all writers / directors / producers / actors are hardcore liberals, yet none of them see the irony in that the villains hold their same political views while they view themselves as “saviors” in real life.

  31. avatar Treedodger says:

    Double standards and hypocrisy do not exist in the progressive world. They are never explained or even acknowledged. They are simply ignored.

  32. avatar Henry says:

    Cognitive dissonance is a progressive way of life. That’s why gun-banner Natalie Portman has absolutely no problem in portraying gunslinging Queen Amidala.

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

button to share on facebook
button to tweet
button to share via email