By LC Judas
Each of the colors in the rainbow of self defense rounds, above, has its own purpose. Its dedicated group of proponents and detractors. Each slot in the spectrum is different from the others, but not all are given the same respect. Case in point: the red-headed stepchild of duty calibers – the .40 S&W. It may be considered superfluous by a lot of shooters, but when Smith & Wesson came up with this round, they changed the game . . .
In 1990 the .40S&W cartridge was designed to score a fat government contract with the FBI. Essentially, it was designed to take the place of lightly loaded 10mm rounds that were used by shooters who didn’t like the full-powered variety. The ballistics of the round were considered great at the time and are still more than passable today.
I got into shooting with a stock Glock 23 in .40S&W. Truth be told, that’s not a way you want to start any new shooter. The main reason being that a .40 polymer pistol isn’t terribly forgiving to a shooter trying to get over (or avoid developing) a flinching habit. And a .40’s snap and flash have induced plenty of cases of the yips in both new and experienced shooters.
So yes, that’s a drawback, but the caliber itself offers better muzzle energy and weight over 9mm when you compare similar loads. And it can do all this with less flash and recoil than its closely-related brother, the .357 SIG.
But let’s assume the typical human isn’t a walking ballistics calculator, nor are they also willing to tote a .50BMG rifle to assure target incapacitation for typical personal defense needs. To select a carry gun, most people run through a mental calculation, taking into account a number of factors. So let’s run the math.
To pick the right gun for you, you’ll need:
~ Enough rounds in your caliber of choice to handle the kinds of situations you anticipate are most likely crop up. Be that 5 rounds in a .38 Smith 642 or 19+1 in a 9mm Springfield XDM.
+ Security in the “stopping power” (air quotes used sarcastically) of your caliber and round choice, whatever flavor of the rainbow you prefer. I’ve met people who will talk you to death on the greatness of .22LR and others who claim to conceal a .50AE Desert Eagle on a regular basis. Whatever doesn’t sink your particular boat.
– Any recoil beyond your physical ability to control so that you can handle the pistol and keep it reliably on target – a subjective decision.
– Bulk, size and weight that you can’t comfortably carry in your typical style of dress. Here the heater frequently takes a back seat to style and seasonal considerations, which can mean less firepower (in the form of a smaller package or even none at all) rather than a change of clothes.
= Some general idea of a caliber and size of weapon for your lifestyle.
You take those four criteria and a few others — form factor, make of weapon, type of action, trigger, what you have experience shooting and what you trust — and then come up with a few choices east of the equal sign.
Now, being as arbitrary as a .40 Glock fanboy can be, six years ago I ran that equation and came up with an answer that equaled something compact with at least 12 rounds of a caliber bigger than 9mm. But since that was unlikely to come in a .45 package with the size and capacity I wanted, my choices ultimately came down to either the Glock 23 or the H&K USP Compact.
Since then I’ve run similar equations for determining what I’d carry for funerals, weddings and as a daily service weapon. And each situation can result in a different answer. For instance, I’m comfortable with a full size double stack 9mm on duty given the likelihood of being fired upon and having to return fire with plenty of capacity.
For a funeral or wedding, when I can’t conceal a larger capacity gun, I’m content with my Kahr P9 with 7+1 and a spare magazine because it’s manageable for its size, accurate and concealable. It’s also comfortable to carry all day and usually gets me past impromptu hugs without relatives wondering what that bulge is.
But back to the .40…it’s not for every occasion. But because nearly all .40 cal pistols share frame dimensions with their 9mm counterparts, you can usually find one that fits the carry situation you anticipate.
Tactically, in a full size double stack duty weapon, you (usually) lose 2 rounds if you’re going to carry .40 vs. 9mm. In the case of the Kahr P9, you lose only one. So most of the time you can do whatever you want with a .40 (in the same size and weight) that you would with a 9mm. It’s a great, versatile middle choice for EDC carry.
As I mentioned, there are plenty that consider the .40 neither here nor there. Less capacity and more recoil than a 9mm without the ballistics and stopping power of a .45. But for the reasons I already mentioned, it’s versatile and satisfies the guys who won’t carry anything that doesn’t start with a 4.
It suits what I imagine my needs to be and doesn’t weigh down my pants and make sitting a hassle like a threaded barrel 1911 in an IWB holster does. But it isn’t a caliber I have trouble believing will stop a potential adversary. I also handle it well, not only on the days I re-qualify, but also on the days I just go plinking at the range. In short, for me it’s the answer to my personal equation and it works.
Talk about someone writing an article with a closed mind, this case showed us that one well trained, armed man can resist.
It took all of the resources the LEO’s in the area could bring to bare to track down this one guy and he still killed or wounded 4 LEO’s.
What would have happened if it wasn’t just one guy..but two..or four…or fourty?
What would happen if you have 100 Chris Dorners running around in the area right around L.A.? At some point the manpower runs out and while you might get some of them, others will remain well hidden. at some point choices are made to protect and secure this area and not that area. We see it with our street gangs. While 100% of shootings may be solved in Beverly Hills , what precentage are solved in south central?
As was pointed out, if only 10% of gun owners in America decided to resist the Government the combined Army, Marine Core and Reserve troops + leos would be outnumbered by many times. Yet one man has shown that he can tie down massive amounts of resources.
I am very fond of hunting i read blog or magazine, about for hunting This blog is so nice to me My problem I live in a forest is not the place For his passion for hunting, leaving his wife and children go alone Out of the country go Whenever I go I take my camera and go with many things For example, my laptop, guns, mobile, camera, etc.pouch for laptop and mobile phone in his from an online site wireless phone accessories I took a lot from this site I’ll take your mobile with this hunt that I’ll make a video This video is my helper, and then missed I still 50, or 60 hunt have been i am very happy for this site you check this site i hope you really like this site
Needs more cow bell!
My dept issues more .40 cal Glocks than 9mm or .45 ACP (over 700 sworn officers). We’ve planted plenty of felons with the 180 gr. GDHP over the years and have been using .40’s since the since the early ’90’s. I can assure you it works just fine. Oh yea, we’ve seen 9mm & .45 fail by the way. Dumping the 147gr 9mm for a 124gr made a difference but, the laws of physics have yet to be repealed. I too carry a .40 cal & have the utmost confidence it its abilities.
This has been interesting to say the least.
Al in all, I shoot all three calibers, several times per week. They all have their places.
Anyone trying to say the 40 is not a good round is just plain foolish. It works just fine when it is needed. Everyone can choose what they shoot best, then go with it.
I apriciated the authors thoughts and have to wonder why so many have to act as though their penis was stepped on when another caliber ( than their preferred ) is mentioned. We all have a sweet spot in our skills, and the are never going to match up exactly the same.
Stay safe, train often. And let the bad guys be on the receiving end of the bullets.
Here I go again, getting sucked into another “mine is better’n yours” threads.
Well, mine IS better than yours – for me…
9mm shines best as a compact handgun that meets minimal requirements for solid and predictable performance outcomes!
If I were going to carry a full sized handgun, now I will start rethinking my carry / caliber options a little deeper.
Just so happens, I do carry a full sized handgun, and it’s chambered in .40SW.
Why?
Let’s be honest, either of the calibers, 9mm or .40 will typically get you over the “stop them now”hump, but what iff????
This one particular evening you and your spouse are out to dinner, and while walking across the parking lot to return home, two obvious idiots want your money, your car keys, and your wife…?
Both are about 6’-6”, about 280lb, and look like Olympic weightlifters.
They also appear to be tweaking pretty bad, and they smell like cat piss from their meth hits minutes ago.
Be honest – do you still want your 9mm, or your 40SW with a quility 155gr defensive load in your full sized weapon of choice between the two calibers, or a 9mm with a well respected 124gr jhp defensive load??
Me?
I’ll take the .40.
Why??
ME – Me’s like the typical wider wound channel the larger caliber offers over the 9mm. Yes, I know that the additional channel size TYPICALLY does not matter MUCH, but in this case, it might make the difference of my belonging and my wife going home with those guys instead of me. If that MIGHT doesn’t cost me anything, sign me up please!
Looking at external ballistics between the two, sign me up for the .40 here too.
Capacity difference?
If I need 17 rounds vs the .15 rounds in my .40, I really needed a belt fed 12ga anyway.
To sum it up,,,
Full sized guns, go with the larger calibers. .40cal doesn’t really come into its glory unless your barrel length is at least 4”, or better. Mine is 4 1/2”, and I’m comfortable here.
3 1/2”, or shorter, yes give me a 9mm. At this point, I’d trade any ballistic advantage my .40 really no longer has, for an additional 2rd cap of the 9mm.
The exception on barrel length here is with the .45acp.
Yes, a fabulous full sized handgun round, but still not better typically than a 4” .40, unless shooting .45+P rounds, or some silly $3 each boutique round, and even in a full sized .45, the recoil with these loads could start getting distracting.
My opinions. Everyone has their own too, all opinions that agree with me are respected!
Lol, just kidding..