Subscribe now to get the latest news on guns, gear, gun rights, and personal defense delivered straight to your inbox daily!

Required fields are bold...

Email Address:
First Name:
Zip Code:

Irresponsible Gun Owner of the Day: NYC Transit Cop

Stress does funny things to people. You can run faster, jump higher, maybe even lift a car off a kid. Some people say things seem to slow down and it’s easier to process what’s going on. Not all of the things stress can do to you are good, though. For example, there’s that whole red mist thing. Tunnel vision, too. As a New York transit cop found out Tuesday night, the negative side effects of stress can also include involuntary muscular contractions . . .

We don’t mean one of those “if it persists for four hours call your doctor” things, either. We’re talking about trigger fingers. A couple of LEOs had just stopped Richard Pearson who’d taken off after committing a petty theft. We’ll let take it from there once they’d caught up with him:

“Police, don’t move. Get down,” the officers told Pearson.

Pearson — who earlier allegedly tried to snatch a cell phone from a woman nearby — tossed the wad of stolen cash and dropped facedown on the sidewalk, cops said.

But Pearson then tucked his hands under his body as the officers tried to cuff him.

That’s when one of the coppers moved to holster his gun while trying to control Pearson with the other.

But the Sig Sauer 9-mm. pistol went off, firing one round into Pearson’s right calf, cops and witnesses said.

“It happened like an accident, he tried to put the gun back and bang — it went off,” one witness said.

“I thought my finger was off the trigger,” the cop allegedly said after the accidental discharge.

And you know what? He may very well have had his finger off the trigger. Only not far enough.

Think it can’t happen to you? Greg Ellifritz posted a recent piece at on finger positioning and hand clenches that probably goes a long way toward explaining what happened to the hapless transit cop.

Many shooters hold their fingers this way (along the outside of the trigger guard) when not firing.  They believe that since the finger is not on the trigger, an accidental discharge won’t occur.  In general, they are correct.  But most shooters don’t know that certain situations can cause an involuntary hand clenching.  The tightening of the hand causes a contraction of all of the fingers with a force up to 30 lbs. (the Glock trigger pull weight is around 6 lbs.) and cannot be consciously controlled.

So the transit cop was probably right. He likely did have his finger off the SIG’s bangswitch. Until, that is, the perp resisted and he was forced to use his off hand to grab the dood and help his partner restrain him. When his gun hand naturally clenched, too, (Big Apple twelve pound trigger or not), well, you know.

To avoid this, Ellifritz points out that a trigger digit needs to be held up higher, lying along the side of the pistol’s frame. His Ayoob-ness agrees, but likes to see the finger curled rather then lying flat on the slide. (see pics at the Ellifritz link).  Either technique probably would have avoided the hole suddenly appearing in Richard Pearson’s calf. All that takes training and practice, though, to develop the muscle memory to do it consistently and instinctively.

But to coin a phrase, it is what it is. While he can cite his central nervous system as an accomplice in the negligent discharge, the transit cop did fire his gun and Pearson will be limping his way to Rikers Island once he’s out of the hospital. All of which means he’s our IGOTD this lovely morning. And we hope that when he ultimately reads about the honor that’s been bestowed upon him, he clicks through and checks out Ellifitz’s words of wisdom.



  1. avatar Henry Bowman says:

    “Police, don’t move. Get down.”

    Gotta love those conflicting orders from guys who will shoot you if you don’t comply.

    1. avatar James says:

      “Well, which is it, young feller? You want I should freeze or get down on the ground? Mean to say, if’n I freeze, I can’t rightly drop. And if’n I drop, I’m a-gonna be in motion. You see… ”

      “Shut up!”

      1. Awesome obscure Coen reference.

        1. avatar BlinkyPete says:

          You a Coen Bros. fan or something?

    2. avatar Accur81 says:

      If a loaded firearm was pointed your way, you would know exactly what that means.

  2. avatar Aharon says:

    We must pass a law requiring the police to be restricted to carrying double-action only revolvers (hammers de-horned) with about eleven pound triggers. No more semi-autos with light trigger pulls. If it can save but one innocent life…

    1. Well in NYC they have 12lb triggers on their pistols, so your comment is irrellavent. Plus it is universally considered that 4.5-5lbs is sufficients for duty an carry use. Any more makes it more difficult to shoot and make the police less accurate. It’s not a coincidence that NYC cops are notorious for their lack of accuracy.

      1. Heavier trigger pulls do not Make for a safer weapon, it is an illusion. The proper way to make it safer is proper operator training and responsible use.

    2. avatar Aharon says:

      I can’t believe you guys thought I was being serious.

  3. avatar GS650G says:

    Doesn’t matter. The perp won’t be stealing phones after the settlement check clears.

    1. avatar jwm says:

      yeah he will. an azzhole with money is still an azzhole. he was probably stealing to feed a drug habit and we know what wise investments druggies make. and to the other issue here “bad cop. no donut.” actually i understand this mishap a lot better than the later being shot in her own backyard by the sd sheriffs dept.

      1. avatar Aharon says:

        Do you think this shooting is possibly a result of the cop having recently eaten at a donut shop and suffering from a sugar-induced high? If so then we must ban cops from eating donuts while on duty.

        1. avatar jwm says:

          you bring up an interesting point. donut glaze made his hands slippery….

      2. avatar matt says:

        he was probably stealing to feed a drug habit and we know what wise investments druggies make.

        Just a FYI, but chances are your investment broker is a coke head, pot head or alcoholic.

        1. avatar Moonshine7102 says:

          And so the point is proven. [rimshot]

        2. avatar jwm says:

          that’s why i use my wife’s mormon connections, it’s no guarantee that they’ll be drug or alcohol free, but i like my odds better with them.

    2. avatar SD3 says:

      Instant justiz, bitchez.

    3. avatar Sanchanim says:

      nah he was resisting and the cops were in fear of their life lol

  4. avatar Sammy says:

    And the citizens pick up the tab. The FOP should have to pay any damages.

  5. avatar Michael B. says:

    I try to place my index fingertip on the side of the slide if I can.

  6. avatar tdiinva says:

    I think the officer only deserves an honorable mention. This was all stress related cojoined with common practice.

  7. avatar Roll says:

    Stuff happens is stressful situations. Looks bad for the cop, but not really sorry for the perp in this instance (hopefully he will learn not to steal from others).

  8. avatar Kvjavs says:

    I’m waiting for a certain firearms instructor to comment on how it’s fine to keep your finger within the trigger guard, or even on the trigger when dealing with a suspect.

    1. avatar Michael B. says:


    2. avatar David says:

      Much as I often disagree with him, in all fairness, Mas Ayoob doesn’t advocate placing your finger inside the trigger guard. Instead he teaches students to hook their partially curled trigger fingers on the outside edge of the guard.

      (Like when I hook my fingernail on the edge of my own trigger guard when I’m at, ‘low ready’ or taking a sight picture on the target.)

      The rest of the time I keep my trigger finger out straight and along THE TOP of the trigger guard. This is a pistol handling technique that has served me well for many years BEFORE Mas Ayoob finally popularized it. Furthermore, I only use this technique in anticipation of immediately firing the pistol. As long as you DO NOT DO THIS ON THE DRAW, you should be fine.

      If you know what you’re supposed to be doing with a pistol AND HAVE THE GUN-HANDLING HABITS TO MATCH this, ‘hooked trigger finger technique’ is safe and works well. If, however, you’re a new or lightly experienced pistolero, then, maybe not. (And, I’m no Ayoob fan – OK!)

  9. avatar Mark says:

    I never argue with the wisom of his Ayoob-ness or his Cooper-ness.

  10. avatar Ralph says:

    Another gun that just went off. Those sneaky bastards have a mind of their own, don’t they?

    1. avatar Sanchanim says:

      I know aren’t they! Less coffee for the guns I tell you!!

  11. avatar Five 0h says:

    And thats why LE is supposed to be trained never go hands on with a weapon in hand. Sounds like 2 officers on scene, one should provide cover and the other go hands on. Simple, or so one would think.

  12. avatar gold price says:

    Maybe the cop should have shot the guy in the trigger finger to stop the threat. Makes ad Mich sense as shooting him in the leg or using rubber bullets. And the guy did not die for shoplifting. He died for armed robbery, threatening an officer, and endangering the lives of every person in the area. He racked up more strikes than the mariners pitching staff.

  13. avatar Kendahl says:

    One of the things I like about the 1911 design is that it has a thumb safety which is very easy to engage or disengage as needed. With it engaged, there is essentially no chance that it will fire. With most striker fired pistols, anything that pulls the trigger fires the gun. It doesn’t even have to be your finger. Just getting some fabric caught in the trigger guard while reholstering can be sufficient.

  14. avatar bontai Joe says:

    Considering the results of the NYC police shooting 9 bystanders in Manhatten, I’d give this officer a medal, one accidental shot and they still hit the bad guy and no one else. Better results than the typical NYC police shooting.

  15. avatar Shea says:

    It’s amazing that you can have an accidental discharge with the reported 12lb trigger pull required for NYPD sidearms.

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

button to share on facebook
button to tweet
button to share via email