It has been nearly six months since I received a care package in the mail from the fine folks at KG Coatings that contained a mixed bag of lubricants and solvents. Now that I’ve depleted my healthy stock of chemicals, it’s time to finally render judgement. All ratings below are subjective and based on a 5-star scale.
KG-1 Carbon Remover – $5.99 (4 oz.) – Rating: * * * * *
The Claim: KG-1 was the first product introduced to the shooting sports industry to specifically meet the need to remove carbon buildup and is the first step in the cleaning process. KG-1 is formulated to be environmentally friendly and contains no ammonia. Recommended for use by several barrel makers. KG-1 is pH neutral and is ideal for removing carbon from black powder rifles, centerfire, rimfire, automatic and gas assisted weapons.
My testing protocol for KG-1 was to shoot something until it got really dirty and then see how little work I had to do to get it clean. Initially, I started with my Ruger 10/22 which was already dirty. Shooting 500 rounds of WalMart’s finest only made that worse. A few dabs of KG-1, a mild nylon brush scrub, and a rinse with KG-3 and things were like new. Naturally, this only piqued my curiosity. So I sought out the dirtiest pistol I could find. Above, you’ll see before and after pictures of a barrel from a 9 mm XD(m) that has seen 2000+ rounds without cleaning. Moving the barrel from dirty to clean took less than 10 minutes. As a final test, I yanked the gas tube out of my AR to find some baked on gunpowder. I coated the tube in KG-1, let it sit for 5 minutes, and wiped it with a clean cloth to find a shiny new gas tube.
KG-1 is probably the most effective carbon killer I’ve ever seen. It doesn’t smell, it doesn’t stain, and it has a bit of oil to it that helps it stick. My new cleaning routine is to hang the gun muzzle down, soak the barrel with KG-1 for 10 minutes, and then brush, flush, and push clean patches through. My guns have never been cleaner.
KG-2 Bore Polish – $6.99 (2 oz.) – Rating: * * * *
The Claim: KG-2 was originally developed to maintain the bore integrity of sniper rifles. Unlike most other mechanical products, KG-2 contains no ammonia and is a 1200-1400grit soft compound to remove copper and lead, while leaving the integrity of the bore. In most cases KG-2 will perform exceptionally well in removing copper and lead with quality patches, however, in some cases, nylon brushes are recommended. Based on the theory of removing the copper and lead from the lands and groves only, while simply smoothing over the impregnated copper and lead in the micro-fractures of the bore, KG-2 will help reduce the need for fouling shots and it is recommended and used by SWAT and sniper teams. KG-2 is an ideal product for fire polishing (A technique producing a finer finish than Fire Lapping).
While KG-1’s effect is immediately apparent, KG-2’s claim to fame is a bit harder to test. I don’t do enough long range shooting to really see an effect from fouling shots (and honestly none of my guns seem to need them). What it has done is make cleaning up easier. I used to push patch after patch after patch to clean up a barrel and now I can get to a clean barrel in less than 5 patches.
The guys at Gunwerks use it as part of their cleaning regimen and they regularly shoot things past half a mile. Since I never saw those guys doing anything unnecessary, I’m willing to say it probably works as intended. Beyond that, I can only say that it seems to be keeping my bore from fouling as hard.
KG-3 Solvent & Degreaser – $9.99 (19 oz.) – Rating: * * * * *
The Claim: KG-3 is a non-chlorinated ozone safe formula used to remove the residue loosened by KG-1, KG-2, KG-12 and for cleaning and degreasing parts. KG-3 contains a special formulation of fast drying, water-displacing solvents which will rapidly cut through oil and grease without leaving a residue.
I’ll fess up to say that I normally buy case after case of brake cleaner from the neighborhood automotive parts house. And for anything metal, that works fine. However, my plastic guns have not fared well with this treatment. They get ugly discoloration spots that are nearly impossible to remove. As such, I’ve had to resort to using an oil based solvent like Hoppes #9 which I can never quite remove. So my options were always a.) slightly oily gun or b.) discolored plastic gun. KG-3 has settled that debate as it does a jam up job of flushing debris, making a perfectly clean surface, AND it doesn’t discolor plastic.
KG-12 Big Bore Cleaner – $9.99 (4 oz.)- Rating: * * * * *
The Claim: KG-12 was developed specifically to clean the copper fouling from large bore military weapons. KG-12 provides professional shooters, gunsmiths, armorers, hunters and other firearm enthusiasts with a product that will remove the toughest copper fouling without damaging the bore. Unlike ammonia-based products, there is no need to neutralize KG-12 or to remove it quickly because KG-12 contains no ammonia.
By far, the most exciting of the chemicals I tested, KG-12 is magical at removing copper. I know this from 3 experiments, two of them planned.
1.) I attempted to melt a copper jacketed bullet with KG-12. I was successful in removing a decent amount of copper before I realized how much KG-12 I was wasting squirting it on bullets & giggling.
2.) I filled the barrel of the aforementioned XD(m) with KG-12 after completely cleaning it using KG-1 & KG-3. I soaked it for 30 seconds and drained the liquid through two cotton patches (see above). That nasty circle is copper residue that was removed from the barrel.
3.) The most unintentional, strangely hilarious, and illuminating was a complete accident. After a thorough cleaning session, I threw an uncapped bottle of KG-12 into my cleaning supplies box. with a brass cleaning rod I recently purchased, a steel core cleaning brush, a brass brush, and a variety of steel bits. Two days later, I opened the box to find a half empty bottle of KG-12, some soaked steel bits, and a mangled mass of brass pieces. Chemistry grads will remember that brass is an alloy of zinc and copper. And KG-12 eats through copper like crazy.
After those three tests, I’m confident that there isn’t a copper fouled barrel in existence that can’t be restored with KG-12.
My overall feeling is positive on the KG cleaners. That Bore Polish is dark magic but people who know more than I do swear by it. Everything else on the list was totally awesome and I will enthusiastically endorse it.
KG-12 is the best copper remover I have ever used. Nothing comes close to it that I have tried.
Many thanks for the review and info.
Do they also provide healthcare for the lung or skin cancer from these chemicals?
You will notice our intrepid reviewer has donned the correct PPE (Personal Protective Equipment) for his foray in the wild world of gun cleaning products.
Which chemical do you use?
I believe you get the healthcare via your mandatory insurance at the HHS exchange.
I’ll bite. Just ordered one of their blister packs that contain all four of the products you recommended. I like trying new cleaning products. Means I have to burn up some ammo and get some guns dirty.
Thanks for the info. I like things like this; helps make sense in a market that is ever increasing in complexity.
2000 rounds without cleaning? I get all eye twitchy when I get close to 200…..
Glad to see some press on this. I have been using for about a year and have had great success. I prefer systems or families of cleaners for cleaning at home and save the all in ones for the range bag.
They all sound like they work great! Can’t wait to watch you use them to clean all my dirty guns next time you are home!
I’m going to have to test the carbon remover on the muzzle crown of my AR, which gets seriously fouled and hard-crusted from shooting Soviet 7N6 milsurp 5.45×39. Even better, the crown is barely accessible with the muzzle brake installed.
Hoppes 9, which takes the carbon off everything else, barely touches this stuff. I’m looking forward to trying the KG cleaner on it.
I was just thinking the same thing, my AK 74 piston, muzzle brake and crown area get dirty and stay dirty.
In 50 years Ive never seen Hoppes remove carbon. It removes powder fouling as does anything else, but not hard carbon. Proved it many times to people who cleaned with Hoppes until clean patches came out. Borescope proves them wrong every time
Neato, I’ll have to check their stuff out whenever I run out of my seemingly endless supply of Hoppe’s #9 and Frog Lube.
Shipping costs for these products are high, are they that toxic? Are there any re-sellers to get a better deal from?
Did you click the Midway link (prices)?
How about the black on the face of a revolver cylinder?
Note: keep the copper solvent away from anything with a satin nickle finish. Many satin nickel or chrome finishes have an underlaying coat of copper. I’ve seen some otherwise perfectly good revolvers with their finish flaked away because a copper solvent ate the under layer.
If K-1 doesn’t smell, how is it going to lock in the warm memories for young shooters that Hoppe’s-9
has for me. One sniff and I can feel the Marlin/Glenfield Mod 25 bolt 22 in my hand.
Since it doesn’t smell you can just open the Hoppes #9 for the aroma while you are cleaning with the KG-1.
How effective is this line of products on corrosive powders?
I guess I just don’t shoot enough.
2K rounds a month of something anything that goes bang,
I go maybe through 300-1000 rounds before cleaning my guns, except my tiny little Beretta 22.
The 22 hates me using dirty Thunderbolts in it so that gets cleaned 3 or 4 times (500 rounds)a range session.
Im still on the same quart bottle of #9 I bought back in the 90s…………….sigh.
Might be a while before I get to buy some of this newer miracle stuff.
How does KG3 compare with most other industrial solvent / degreaser aerosols? I’ve used KG3 for a few years now & it’s good, but just wondered about cheaper alternatives. Here in the U.K. a can of this is around £13.00 ($18.00+)