Home » Blogs » Connecticut, Cook County File Lame Opening Briefs In U.S. Supreme Court AWB Challenge

Connecticut, Cook County File Lame Opening Briefs In U.S. Supreme Court AWB Challenge

Mark Chesnut - comments 11 comments
St. Paul Minnesota city hall where gun control ordinance was passed

The opposing governments in the combined U.S. Supreme Court case challenging the ban on so-called “assault weapons” have filed their opening briefs laying out why their bans meet the demands of the Constitution.

And a major gun-rights organization isn’t too impressed with the arguments made by Cook County, Illinois, and the state of Connecticut.

The two cases, Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins, challenge bans on rifles commonly owned and used for lawful purposes by millions of Americans, including those in Connecticut and Cook County.

In its brief, Cook County argues that it can regulate the firearms in question because they are exceptionally dangerous, lethal, and prone to misuse.

“The Second Amendment secures the right to keep and bear arms, but like other rights enshrined in our Constitution, it is not absolute,” the brief states. “The Framers did not intend to permit the possession or use of ‘any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose.’ This principle is deeply rooted in our Nation’s history, which is replete with common-sense regulations of weapons that are exceptionally dangerous, lethal, and prone to misuse. When weapons are introduced into society that have the capability to perpetrate some of our most tragic and frightening crimes, from mass shootings to assassination attempts, democratically elected legislators are permitted to respond with appropriate regulation.”

The Delaware brief made a similar, unpersuasive argument.

“From fourteenth-century England to twenty-first century America, governments have restricted weapons because of their unusually dangerous properties,” the brief argues. “And although the weapons have evolved—from the launcegay to the Bowie knife to the Tommy gun—the rationale behind those laws has not. In each instance, legislatures have determined that a weapon is atypically lethal relative to its peers—and so have acted to prevent that weapon’s use.”

The Second Amendment Foundation, a plaintiff in both of the lawsuits says the laws are blatantly unconstitutional, despite the arguments otherwise.

“Categorical bans on the most commonly owned rifles in America violate the Second Amendment, full stop,” SAF Executive Director Adam Kraut said in a news release announcing the filing of the briefs. “Unfortunately, countless peaceful Americans across the U.S. are subject to these unconstitutional bans, which single out and demonize modern semi-automatic rifles for nonsensical reasons like the adjustability of a shoulder stock or angle of a grip. The Supreme Court has already laid out a clear method of analysis for statutes like these—and has set constitutional standards that these laws simply fail to meet. The opposition briefs filed attempt ‘creative’ tactics to avoid those standards—or challenge them outright—and we are confident the Court will not be persuaded. We look forward to filing our reply and responding directly to these poorly conceived positions.”

Alan M. Gottlieb, SAF founder and executive vice president, Gottlieb said it is high time that assault weapons bans “recede back into the primordial ooze of gun control legislation from which they emerged.”

“One might think Supreme Court caselaw explaining that arms in ‘common use’ are protected by the Second Amendment, and bans on a rifle owned by more than 30 million law-abiding citizens would be incompatible, yet here we are,” Gottlieb said. “Anti-gun zealots appear willing to cling to these laws despite the weight of the Constitution being against them.”

Plaintiffs in the case are currently preparing their reply briefs addressing the arguments made by Cook County and Delaware.

11 thoughts on “Connecticut, Cook County File Lame Opening Briefs In U.S. Supreme Court AWB Challenge”

  1. The elements and arguments in both of the court briefs presented in this article are exactly why the founding fathers limited the text of the Second Amendment to only twenty seven words.

    Reply
  2. Ignores relevant time frame, seeks interest balancing, involves foreign nations history and rules. Let’s see if the court means what it said in Bruen.

    Reply
  3. I have written many many appellate briefs, and I can tell you that from my experience, Cook County’s brief is a poor product. It is not well thought out nor well written. You’d think they’d have done a much better job, but all they did is regurgitate their prior arguments to the Illinois courts.

    By the way, these are not their “opening briefs,” these are their briefs. They don’t get another bite at the apple.

    And by he way, a couple of gun control groups filed an Amicus brief asking the Court to overturn Heller as a catastrophic decision and simply unsupportable. Sorry guys, ain’t gonna happen.

    Reply
  4. My reply to these anti freedom briefs would be learn the real history of the 2A. Then I would ask how stupid are you? Hopefully they take the question as a challenge to show more stupidity.

    Reply
  5. The problem is accepting the following: “common-sense regulations of weapons that are exceptionally dangerous, lethal, and prone to misuse.”

    When the 6 shot metallic cartridge revolver and lever action repeating rifle came onto the scene, it was the opinion of the Ordnance Corp in many nations that the result was the consumption of too much ammunition. The consensus was slowly acquired sighting and long distance shooting was the only appropriate method, using as little ammunition as possible. One known defect in this policy was the battle in Africa with a small unit vs thousands of Zulu warriors – and issuing ammo from a single wagon by hand of less than 20 rounds during the firefight.

    War is much much more consumptive of ammo than that, and leaning toward the explicit language that the private citizen is the real militia in America, being undersupplied isn’t the fix. One could point to the “rooftop Koreans” as an example of how it works in the real world, or the response to the famous bank robbery in LA where the police were undergunned and literally took weapons offered from a nearby dealer to attempt to match what the robbers had.

    What the gun banners refuse to admit is that despite all the law proposed and passed, it didn’t stop criminals from obtaining and using firearms in the least. What happens in real life is limiting the response of the people – the first responders on almost every scene – to be able to immediately engage and stop. When you get into the dirty details of what a weapon does, those that excel at being “exceptionally dangerous and lethal.” are the entire point and the result of centuries of careful development. There actually aren’t any weapons that aren’t dangerous and lethal in that regard -but many considered by the primary purpose, such as kitchen knives, baseball bats, or the simple rock – all much more commonly used in crimes against the people – by the people. Nothing much is ever proposed to limit them.

    What the opponents of gun ownership really want is to only have their hired thugs to possess them to collectively oppress citizens. Note carefully – they NEVER suggest that their own police or national defenses be disbanded and eliminated as the primary show of belief that “guns are bad.” Nope, they continue to employ their own personal bodyguards or assign the existing capacity to protect them as they work to destroy our rights. Need an example? “Peaceful protesters” who are opposed by property owners or patriots who disallow their possessions being vandalized or burned then CALL THE COPS to stop citizens who oppose their depredations. Hypocrisy at its height and done even more now.

    If there are weapons that are misused and exceedingly dangerous, I would point to pallets of bricks left at planned demonstration points of conflicts, and why there hasn’t been any enforcement on that goes to the local jurisdiction deliberately encouraging crime, not preventing it. Shop and business owners should have collectively sued the masonry supplier and ruined them – that is enforcement. So is defending your property by making use of an even more dangerous and lethal weapon. They are NOT going away, any more than automobiles – which kill far more annually – or cell phones – which are used in crime daily by drug dealers and elected officials in DC. Its why the FBI seizes them investigating immigration crime.

    Reply
  6. The stupidity of anti’s is unbelievable. My .270 deer rifle is far more lethal than a 5.56 or 223. Most deer rifles are but they don’t look as an AR or AK does. Imagine the damage of 170 grain .270’s flying at you .Step up to a 30.06 and then step in front of one of those

    Reply
  7. Cook County and Illinois are just carrying the sign that the 7th Circuit gave them when it decided that MSRs are not “arms” for purposes of the 2A. I was at the argument for the cases where that was decided; very sad.

    Reply
  8. Every gun can be lethal. Guns were made to stop threat’s, hunt and defend lives. A single shot .22 rifle can kill just like an AR-16. An AR is a great home defence weapon. It is compact compared to a long rifle, making easer to use in close quarters. It is also a great choice for women and those of short stature. For those who don’t know an AR is a Carbine a short barrel rifle, not a long rifle.

    Reply
  9. What I find infuriating is the propensity of the gun-banners for group punishment. Although there may be some, I can’t think of other types of crimes that require an entire class of people to suffer punishment for the crime of a single individual.

    Reply

Leave a Comment