Home » Blogs » Oregon Man Broke Gun Law to End a School Shooting

Oregon Man Broke Gun Law to End a School Shooting

TTAG News Contributor - comments 14 comments
Gun-free school zone sign attached to a chain-link fence, featuring a crossed-out firearm symbol and a warning about criminal penalties.

Oregon has one of the thickest stacks of state firearms restrictions in the country. None of them stopped a 16-year-old from shooting his way into Silver Rail Elementary last week. What stopped him was a father who defied one of those laws to save lives.

Kaylub Giamanco carried a legally owned handgun onto school grounds — a place where Oregon statute says he wasn’t allowed to carry it — and used it to end the attack. Authorities so far don’t appear to be headed for a prosecution, which is the only sane outcome. But the fact that a prosecution is even theoretically on the table tells you everything you need to know about how these laws were drafted.

Who the Law Actually Deters

Criminals don’t read statutes before offending. That is doubly true of someone who went to an elementary school intending to commit mass murder and probably didn’t plan to walk out alive. If death itself isn’t a deterrent, the possibility of a posthumous firearms-charge add-on carries exactly zero weight.

Gun-free zones are posted for one audience: the law-abiding. They are the only people who read the sign, consider the law, and comply. A killer walks past the sign and keeps going.

J.D. Tuccille made the point sharply in Reason this week, writing that these laws are “clearly more of a threat to people with good intent than it is to those bent on doing harm.” His conclusion was blunt: “Such laws should and must be defied, but lawmakers need to remove these legal minefields before they do more damage.”

The Real Danger

Here is what the laws actually do. They deter good people from being where they could help.

Legal peril carries real weight for law-abiding concealed carriers. The threat of an authoritarian statute enforced by a politically motivated prosecutor is enough to convince plenty of permit holders to leave the gun at home when they drop their kids off. Giamanco didn’t — but he represents the person willing to accept the risk, not the typical response. Talk to carriers in California or New York and plenty will tell you that unless they or their family are in direct danger, they’ll stay out of it. Not because they don’t want to help. Because the consequences of helping could be worse than the consequences of walking away.

Tuccille points to the broader hostility toward self-defense in anti-gun jurisdictions, and he’s right. The architecture of the law in states like Oregon, California, and New York is designed to make the law-abiding ask themselves whether intervening is worth the career-ending prosecution that might follow.

What’s Lawful vs. What’s Right

Giamanco saved an unknown number of lives at Silver Rail, chasing the shooter inside while officers were still arriving. The word “hero” doesn’t cover it. He had to break one of Oregon’s gun laws to earn that title, and the honest conversation Oregon needs to have — and that every state with a similar statute needs to have — is why that was the deal he was offered.

What’s lawful and what’s right aren’t the same thing. They should be. Fix the laws.

14 thoughts on “Oregon Man Broke Gun Law to End a School Shooting”

  1. He’s not gonna be charged with anything that being said yes laws that don’t have a caveat to address situations like this need to be changed.

    Reply
    • Well no, the “Law of Necessity” is the law of the Universe in that if you can aid a person in danger, you do so, regardless of any unconstitutional laws. READ: Federalist Paper 49 by Madison where he speaks of the principle of a republic, no permission to act, no action by government. This fact alone would prove that all federal and state laws on the Right to Arms, are unconstitutional as they are not permitted to government to act upon. Not “Rocket Science” here folks.

      Reply
  2. “What’s lawful and what’s right aren’t the same thing. They should be. Fix the laws.”

    Here is an incredibly valuable pearl of wisdom:

    Many politicians want more influence, control, and wealth. Those same politicians inherently know that the masses will not hand over their lives to those politicians just because the politicians asked. So, those same politicians actively try to create as much chaos and suffering as possible with the explicit intention that the masses will cry out for government solutions which, of course, require the masses to hand over ever more of their lives.

    Let that sink in: it is in politician’s personal interest (to increase their influence, control, and wealth) to facilitate as much chaos and suffering as possible because that inevitably leads to the masses accepting ever more policies which take away from the masses and give to the politicians.

    Reply
    • Communism, as part of its playbook, NEEDS chaos. Because when the chaos gets bad enough, then a large enough contingent of the governed will reach their “tipping point”, and vote in favor of the communism. Even if only to just end the insanity. Which never ends, of course.

      Sometimes, republicans/conservatives can unwittingly participate, encourage, not prevent, or even increase the chaos. We may be seeing a little bit of that during this midterm election period, what with tariffs being applied and removed on a nearly daily basis, going after Iran, having cease fires and “MOUs” that always crash and burn, and being told that high gas prices “are a small price to pay”, and a general sluggishness when it comes to arresting, trying, and punishing people committing fraud and abuse of the American taxpayer.

      When Joe Biden was president, he brought violent barbarian foreign invaders into the country by tens of millions and gave them spending cards. He shut down the pipelines and oil exploration and drilling as well as other energy producing industry, he got some people fired for not bending the knee to the fake doctor Fauxi, and he kept kids out of school while putting alphabet people in the military and the HHS department.

      He put thousands of people in prison and didn’t give them any fair due process, and started calling “maga republicans” and Trump “Nazis”.

      To “afford” all of this, Joe Biden printed money like crazy, creepily whispered “It’s working!” to anybody who would listen, and spending the rest of his time sniffing childrens’ hair and shitting his pants.

      His fellow democrats (and some republicans) in the press and congress (who are also communists) were only too happy to ignore the chaos happening in flyover country and the escalating inflation caused by declining supply of housing, food, fuel, and the increase in the money supply.

      While he was doing all of that, governors Newsom, Walz, and Whitmer were busy raiding the federal money going to their states. Newsom let California burn, Walz let Somali thieves create fake charities, and Whitmer prevented her people from planting tomatoes. It’s all just more chaos.

      The chaos is a tool of the communist who wants to destroy a country.

      We see it throughout history. Chaos paralyzes the best of the citizenry and makes it more of a daily grind just to stay alive and keep your family safe from all the rapists roaming the land. When you’re busy working your ass off and keeping track of all the violence in your community, you have less time to fight the people who are instituting the policies that create all the chaos.

      And you can’t just “go fight them”, because you first have to fight your neighbors, who have fully and completely signed on with the chaos, possibly by way of their “Compliance Bias”. How can you focus on the nutball governor of your state when your neighbor is calling the police because your kids aren’t wearing their masks? How can you focus on the dirty communists in your county government when your community is being overrun by rioters and other barbarians burning down the small businesses of your medium town?

      You can’t. You have to prioritize your safety and your family first, before you can function in any significant capacity against the chaos instigators.

      Communists know this, and that’s why their chaos is always multi-pronged. Like a “fork” in chess, you lose a little bit every day when you have multiple concurrent threats. Your school board just voted to let boys compete against girls in vollyball and now your 13 year old daughter is at risk for paralysis or brain damage. Your 11 year old son’s teacher is working behind your back to get your boy to say he’s really a girl. Your wife can’t go to her bible study on Wednesdays because there’s a feral roaming band of islamist barbarians causing mayhem in the streets, and maybe even raping women near the local catholic church. And YOU have your own shit to deal with. There are women at your work falsely accusing you of a sex crime because one of them saw your family at a church function last week.

      You have multiple threats to deal with BEFORE you can even mount an offense against your governor, county commission, school administration, kids’ teachers, or get the local sheriff to finally arrest and charge some of those feral street barbarians so that they can be deported or thrown into a prison cell.

      Communists know this. They rely on this. They have the judges, cops, sheriff deputies, county commission, teachers, and even the school librarian all working on the communist mission. They have a sizeable portion of your own neighbors automatically deferring to “authority figures”. They have their psy-ops and propaganda arms, and they have their footsoldiers.

      The only tool they’re missing is … gun control. Because when good people carry firearms, they always have a force-multiplier that can help them end some of the chaos. Like the chaos that 16 year old was trying to bring to his old school.

      Reply
    • The ouroboros of praxis using the dialectic has been around as long as people have been.

      The Commies just fleshed out the theory and practice of doing so with technical/philosophical language.

      It comes in a lot of flavors though, and it’s funny to watch people who see it in some places miss the pattern in others.

      Reply
      • Not everybody is good at seeing and recognizing patterns.

        Many are just indoctrinated to “believe the authority figure”, and so they do.

        Reply
        • That is, in and of itself, a form of pattern recognition that leads to a heuristic. They recognize that the “authority figure” is giving signals constant with a pre-conceived position of stature and authority. People then generally default to the heuristic for behavior which is “do what he says”.

          However, the authority figure must follow a pattern of signaling established for that authority figure or their declared position of authority or the heuristic will not simply kick in for the majority.

          Imagine, for example, that a Colonel in, let’s say the US Army, gets up one morning and runs around the base in his underwear with shirt stays attached only to his socks (because of course has shirt stays) screaming about the alien invasion and giving orders to prepare the base to defend against an interplanetary invasion and how his wife’s leaving him because she listened to Elvis played backwards.

          What percentage of those under his command simply snap to and follow his commands? Not many because the Colonel has broken his normal pattern associated with the authority granted by his rank and gone off into one that is commonly seen as “crazy” because it partly follows an established “crazy” pattern and partially has a pattern people see as “undefined”.

          Obviously, to some degree this example may not work with the Air or Space Forces. (I kid, I kid.)

          You see and think in patterns downstream from data filters because that’s how your brain is, quite literally, built.

          The tricky part is seeing the right patterns. See the wrong ones and you’re just wrong. Draw lines between very different dots from everyone else and you’re a genius or crazy.

          This is why training works. It teaches you that if you detect a specific pattern or a pattern within a pre-defined set of patterns you default to a heuristic which is built to deal with the situation that pattern indicates. In
          slightly more complicated terms, this means that someone else has already deduced the meaning of that pattern and taught you the correct (hopefully) behavior derived from that meaning with no necessity to actually have you understand the meaning itself.

          When repeated enough, you can add complex skills and even active reasoning on to the heuristic. This is a form of operant conditioning, we’ve done it to school kids for decades.

          Ex: A bell goes off, the kids all stand up go to their lockers, switch books and go to another room where they sit down for a different class. If a janitors cart is overturned in the hallway, blocking their normal path they don’t walk into it, they generally go around it.

          Reply
  3. The gun owning majority opinion seems to be “lawful”. So saving children & teacher’s lives is only cool if you following gubmint rules?!? Shall not be abridged IS the RULE!

    Reply
    • “Lawful” is just more evidence that “Compliance Bias” (maybe I should call it “Toxic Compliance Bias” or “Suicidal Compliance Bias) just may be more powerful than The Force.

      Even during the American Revolution, it was only a few people who would set aside their compliance bias and fight the authority figure. Imagine if George Washington had decided to just work his farm and keep his head down instead of leading men into battle.

      Reply
  4. I am reminded that Mr. McDonald of McDonald v. Chicago fame was charged with unlawful possession of a firearm resulting from him shooting someone trying to rob him at his “bar.” There are innumerable cases where a homeowner is “detained” after a self-defense shooting pending investigation, investigations which invariably whether the gun is “registered” and lawfully obtained, and whether the homeowner was legally entitled to possess firearms. The victim quickly becomes a perpetrator despite a lawful self-defense shooting.,

    Reply
  5. He won’t be charged for now because it’s too radioactive, politically speaking, to do so.

    That doesn’t mean he won’t be later on when we’re not paying attention. That’s why people set up a pre-arranged charity fund on his behalf for his legal defense, should it become necessary.

    Reply
  6. Don’t hold your breath about Oregon, having an honest conversation about gun law. Nor the second amendment. It will never happen.

    Reply
  7. I don’t expect Giamanco to be charged in direct relation to this attack, but I FULLY expect a campaign of harassment, brought about by agents of a hostile leftist gov’t, to be waged against him in some degree or form. He made them and their ideas look a fool – and there is no possible way they can let him get away with THAT.

    Reply

Leave a Comment