Home » Blogs » Fifth Circuit: 2A Protects the Right to Buy and Sell Guns

Fifth Circuit: 2A Protects the Right to Buy and Sell Guns

TTAG News Contributor - comments No comments
Customer examining a rifle with a gun store employee across the sales counter, with additional firearms displayed in the background.

A three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Thursday that the Second Amendment’s text covers more than keeping and bearing arms, extending its protection to purchasing and selling firearms as well.

The decision came in U.S. v. Deare. The panel reversed a lower court’s denial of Jeremiah Deare’s motion to dismiss his indictment and returned the case to the district court to try again. Deare had been charged with conspiring to deal firearms as a business without a federal firearms license, along with making false statements about records kept by licensed firearms dealers.

The ruling doesn’t automatically clear Deare. It does, however, put states within the Fifth Circuit’s jurisdiction on notice about any future restrictions they might try to place on the purchase and sale of firearms.

The Reasoning

Judge James Ho and Judge Andrew Oldham filed separate concurrences. Ho put the core idea plainly, writing that “it seems obvious that constitutional rights are meaningless if the Government can simply prohibit the means by which citizens are able to exercise those rights.” He drew the obvious parallel: if the Second Amendment doesn’t cover sellers because it never mentions them, then the First Amendment doesn’t cover booksellers either. That can’t be right.

Oldham went after the court’s own prior ruling in Peterson, which treated Bruen’s footnote nine as creating a “presumption of constitutionality for shall-issue licensing regimes” and applied that to the National Firearms Act.

Oldham wrote that neither the word “presumption” nor any variant appears in footnote nine, which only clarified that shall-issue regimes aren’t automatically unconstitutional just because may-issue ones are. Stretching that footnote from carry licenses to registration to firearm sales, he wrote, would mean moving “from football to baseball to ballroom dance.”

Judge Catharina Hayne wrote that the Second Amendment “doesn’t mention sellers,” so “I do not think that the sellers of guns are covered.” Even assuming they were, she saw nothing showing the rules here were unconstitutional, and no reason to remand.

Leave a Comment