Home » Blogs » Federal Judge Strikes Down the NFA’s Registration Scheme for Suppressors and SBRs

Federal Judge Strikes Down the NFA’s Registration Scheme for Suppressors and SBRs

Scott Witner - comments 24 comments
The Seventh Circuit Upholds NFA Restrictions on SBRs in United States v. Rush

A federal judge in Texas just did what gun owners have wanted for 90 years: he told the government that the National Firearms Act’s registration is unconstitutional.

On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge James Wesley Hendrix of the Northern District of Texas granted summary judgment for the plaintiffs in the consolidated cases Jensen v. ATF and Silencer Shop Foundation v. ATF, ruling that the NFA’s registration, application, approval, and enforcement provisions exceed Congress’s enumerated powers as applied to the firearms Congress stopped taxing. That means suppressors, short-barreled rifles (SBRs), short-barreled shotguns (SBSs), and “any other weapons” (AOWs); the exact categories cut loose by last year’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act.

If it survives appeal, it’s the most significant crack in the 1934 law since the day it was signed.

No tax means no registration, and Hendrix said so plainly

The argument here isn’t new, and TTAG readers have watched it build for a year. The NFA has never been a gun-control law in the constitutional sense. It’s a tax law. The Supreme Court upheld it back in 1937 in Sonzinsky v. United States precisely because it was an exercise of Congress’s taxing power; the registration, fingerprints, and ATF approval all existed to administer and collect the $200 stamp.

Then Congress zeroed out that tax. Effective January 1, 2026, the making and transfer taxes on suppressors, SBRs, SBSs, and AOWs dropped to $0, but lawmakers left the registration paperwork in place. That created the absurdity 2A groups have been hammering ever since: a “tax” that collects nothing, propping up a registry that Americans still have to feed their fingerprints and photographs into.

Hendrix wasn’t buying it. “Because today’s NFA does not generate any revenue from untaxed firearms, its regulatory provisions cannot be upheld under the taxing power,” he wrote. With no revenue, there’s no tax. With no tax, there’s no constitutional hook.

DOJ tried to rewrite the law’s history, and the court refused

The government’s fallback was predictable. DOJ argued that even if the taxing power no longer worked, the NFA could stand on the Commerce Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause instead.

Hendrix shut the door on that. Congress, he noted, enacted these provisions under the Taxing Clause and nothing else; there’s no sign in the law’s text, structure, or history that any other power was ever invoked. The government doesn’t get to retroactively bolt on a new justification, decades later, to save a scheme whose original foundation no longer supports it. “The challenged NFA provisions exceed Congress’s Article I enumerated powers and are therefore unconstitutional,” he concluded.

The plaintiffs also raised a Second Amendment challenge, and Hendrix didn’t touch it. He agreed the enumerated-powers argument won and said he didn’t need to reach the constitutional right-to-bear-arms claim.

The injunction covers members and customers, which is a lot of people

Here’s where gun owners need to read carefully before doing anything.

This is not a nationwide order wiping the NFA off the books. Hendrix limited his injunction to the plaintiffs and, “where applicable,” their members and customers.

But look at who the plaintiffs are: Gun Owners of America, the Silencer Shop Foundation, the Firearms Regulatory Accountability Coalition, Palmetto State Armory, SilencerCo, B&T USA, the Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms, the Texas State Rifle Association, individual plaintiffs, and a coalition of 15 pro-gun states. Members of most of the nation’s largest gun-rights organizations are swept in.

So while the order isn’t universal on paper, it reaches an enormous slice of the gun-owning public. This is the payoff from the strategy 2A groups launched the moment the tax repeal passed — the tax cut wasn’t the finish line, it was the opening.

From Silencer Shop: What It Means at the Counter

Silencer Shop Foundation brought this case as lead plaintiff, and it’s already telling buyers what the win looks like in practice. Once the injunction takes effect, a covered customer buying a suppressor through SSF’s dealer network won’t file a Form 4, won’t get entered into the federal registry, and won’t sit on an approval wait. They’ll pass the same background check they’d pass for a rifle and take the can home the same day. As SSF puts it, the free tax stamp Congress passed in January was never the hard part — the registration was, and that’s the piece that just fell.

Two limits SSF is upfront about. First, the timeline: the court issued a seven-day stay, so these changes are currently set to take effect on or about August 12, 2026, assuming the stay isn’t extended. Second, state law: a federal court can’t rewrite it. Suppressors remain flatly illegal for regular folks in nine places — California, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, and Washington, D.C. — and nothing here changes that.

Silencer Shop Foundation is also calling this a beachhead rather than a finish line. The group says it’s already headed back to court to widen the ruling so the injunction protects more than just its own coalition.

DOJ has a week, and an appeal is almost certain

Hendrix stayed his own judgment for seven days to give the Department of Justice time to seek relief at the appellate level. Given that DOJ defended the law aggressively in briefing, leaning on the Commerce Clause and citing binding Fifth Circuit precedent — an appeal to the Fifth Circuit is the safe bet.

So nothing changes today. The registration requirements remain enforceable during the stay, and depending on what the appellate courts do, that could hold for a while. Anyone thinking about running out to buy a can on a Form 4473 right now should pump the brakes until this actually takes effect for the group they belong to.

There’s also a wrinkle worth remembering: several states tie their own suppressor and SBR legality to federal NFA registration. If the federal registry goes away faster than those state statutes get cleaned up, owners in a handful of states could find themselves in a gray area. Kill the NFA the wrong way and you can accidentally strand people. It’s a good problem to have, but it’s still a problem.

The predictable panic has already started

The gun-ban lobby reacted exactly how you’d expect. Giffords Law Center called the decision “a dangerous step backward for public safety,” recycling the tired line that suppressors help active shooters and that short-barreled long guns are uniquely dangerous, claims that fall apart the second you look at how rarely NFA items show up in actual violent crime. It’s the same crowd that’s already trying to reinstate the $200 tax through legislation.

For the rest of us, this is what a nearly century-old tax scam looks like when it finally runs its course. The One Big Beautiful Bill knocked the legs out from under it; a federal judge just made it official on paper.

The fight now moves to the Fifth Circuit, and eventually, everyone assumes, higher. Stay tuned.

Tags News NFA
Photo of author

Scott Witner

Scott Witner is a former Marine Corps Infantryman with 2nd Battalion, 8th Marines, and served with the 24th MEU(SOC) during a six-month deployment to the Mediterranean. He’s completed specialized training in desert warfare, mountain warfare, and jungle operations across the U.S., South Korea, and Japan. With over a decade in the firearms and outdoor industry, Scott has helped leading brands grow their visibility and reach through strategic marketing and content development. He currently resides in Northeastern Ohio, where he enjoys hiking, shooting, and testing related gear in the environments it’s intended to be used in.

24 thoughts on “Federal Judge Strikes Down the NFA’s Registration Scheme for Suppressors and SBRs”

  1. That would be nice because I may know someone who may or may not have a whole slew of unregistered NFA items of all sorts.
    BTW a stocked short barreled 12guage really makes a keen cottonmouth blaster. Or so he may or may not have said.

    Reply
    • You do know that the government can easily find out who you are, right Duly?

      The wise man does not poke the bear…but you’re just a former politician. On the plus side, I hear the Alzheimers care in federal prison is quite good.

      Reply
    • The suppressor had zero to do with it. It was the actions of Salinas that saved lives, he just happens to EDC a gun with a suppressor.

      Reply
  2. RE: “So while the order isn’t universal on paper, it reaches an enormous slice of the gun-owning public. This is the payoff from the strategy 2A groups launched the moment the tax repeal passed — the tax cut wasn’t the finish line, it was the opening.”

    Strategy? In other words the so called big win excludes every law abiding citizen from equally exercising a Constitutional Right. The ruling holds the door open for the continuation of the insanity behind such things as you pilgrims can have a 16″ barrel carbine but go to prision if you have a 14.5″ barrel and fail to weld on an 1.5″ extension. The ruling contends if you are one of the select few who belong to certain country clubs you don’t need a welder to stay out of prison…just yet. Another glorious toothless ruling that caters to self serving crowds of country club Gun talking blowbags.

    Reply
      • I don’t think you know what a Fudd is. A Fudd would be angry that they did anything to strike down the NFA, not angry that this ruling still allows unconstitutional restrictions.

        Reply
        • Let’s see, critical of wins that do not benefit them, willfully ignorant of the judicial process, strong fixations on obsolescent topics, clinging on to racism like it has been relevant for the last 20 years to anyone who isn’t a poverty pimp, and goes for the Rambo wannabe vibe at those who prefer anything tactical while pushing dumb ass products like tire stems to prevent glock leg. Yeah pretty sure I know a FUDD.

          Reply
        • He knows what it means. His comment references previous interactions which you are, apparently, unaware of.

          Debbie has, repeatedly advocated for politically tone-deaf, unworkable and FUDDy solutions to the NFA issue and other gun control issues in general while misunderstanding basic civics and legal procedure.

          Her general position is that she’s not buying anything that’s on the NFA until .gov gives her exactly what she wants and anyone who does buy any of that stuff is stupid and needs to be told, often, that they are stupid.

          Her solution to all of this is to call people racist (in a historical context, of course) until .gov gives her what she wants, which usually is NFA gear via a simple 4473.

          And here in the OP, you see another example of her low intelligence level. She fails to note that whether this is a major victory or not, had people followed her “advice”, this court case wouldn’t have been possible because there would have been no one with standing to launch it. There would, instead, be nothing more than a bunch of low IQ hags blathering about racism on the internet.

          There’s about a eight in 10 chance that she will now reply to this post, calling me names and then referring to me as a “blowbag” who doesn’t have the courage to call the right people “racist”.

          It’s rather tiresome and predictable.

          Anyway, I’ll now take this opportunity, as someone who helped bring this lawsuit to say “You’re welcome, Debbie.”

          Reply
    • Only reasons suppressors and SBR’s are so expensive that only the country club guys can have them is because of the NFA. Europeans can by a no frills for around 100 bucks, no background check either. Which is what it should be here.
      You did raise an interesting question though, if it went to Supreme court and they ruled the same as this case, would states that currently ban NFA items have to end their bans?

      Reply
      • Lol no. Some states would probably do a quick change to reflect some newly non NFA items being normal to not hem up their residents with odd state laws alreadyon the books. Ban states will remain ban states until forced into a corner and stomped unconscious to allow normal rights.

        Reply
        • It would probably require that such issues, in non-ban states, be actively brought to the legislature’s attention.

          I doubt that most state legislature members know about these “tie ins” as they were done decades ago.

          Nearly no one in Colorado seems to understand this, or at least they’re not willing to admit to it. I’m not sure why exactly that is. Part of me suspects that no one wants to admit that Colorado tied its laws to the Federal NFA in the 1990’s under a Republican when “tough on crime” somehow meant “we’re doing something about the scourge of NFA gear in our state” and the ‘tards went along with it.

          Reply
          • Mix of ignorance and greed perhaps? Either actually doesn’t know and doesn’t figure it is worth getting riled up over or knows very well and plans to campaign/fundraise off it if the other laws take a hit down the road.

          • The latter is certainly a factor.

            The D’s are not the only ones who never let a crisis go to waste, especially if they manufactured it.

            It’s almost like incentive structures… matter.

  3. “Anyone thinking about running out to buy a can on a Form 4473 right now should pump the brakes…”

    You don’t have to fill out a 4473 now to buy a suppressor, in fact, if you order one online it’s shipped to your home, not an FFL.

    I don’t understand that comment in the article.

    Reply
  4. You need to understand this completely and not get all excited and start building that SBR…. there is an administrative stay on the injunction so don’t start making or transferring yet.

    Until the administrative stay officially expires and there is no extension, the injunction is not in force. So until the stay is no longer make sure to strictly comply with NFA requirements until then.

    Reply
  5. This was the reason I needed to join up. I picked GOA and joined this morning. Cost $25 a year which is cheap protection. Should cover for any equipment I may or may not have that may or may not comply with the NFA. Maybe I’ll get a can now (when 5th circuit refuses to take up the case, or backs the NDT).

    Reply
  6. This one might be interesting going forward. People in states that link their laws to federal statute or a free-standing ban would be wise to join one of these groups or become a customer of one of the businesses to protect themselves in advance should the judicial system actually strike down the NFA nationwide.

    Kill the NFA the wrong way and you can accidentally strand people. It’s a good problem to have, but it’s still a problem.

    Well sure, as long as you’re not one of those who’s stranded. God forbid we actually plan shit out to try to avoid such a thing.

    But no, as a group we’ll probably take the general Conservative approach of not planning fuck all and then blaming the victim while subtly implying that nice things are for us, not for you. Work? Cons don’t do that. They have day jobs and everything else is someone else’s problem.

    But, to be fair, I can’t wait for the “You could afford to quit your job, move and buy a house if you just gave up the avocado toast and Starbucks, got a roommate, got a cheaper cell phone and were willing to move to an area in the rust belt with no jobs and an epic gang problem!” shit from right coded influencers and the armies of braindead NPCs that follow them.

    Reply

Leave a Comment