Ammo Review: SIG SAUER .44 Special 200gr V-Crown JHP

SIG SAUER has released some of the most innovative ammunition to come to market in recent years. Instead of going wild with expensive materials and processes, they decided to improve upon excellent, existing technology and apply it in creative ways. The V-Crown bullets are one of the best (maybe the best) traditional JHP bullets on the market today. In the course of my testing with the SIG V-Crown line, I have yet to have a failure to perform. Today we are taking a look at perhaps the best thing to happen to the .44 Special since the Keith hardcast was developed: the SIG SAUER 200gr Elite V-Crown JHP.

General Background

In a surprising move, SIG put a significant amount of engineering power into the relatively uncommon .44 Special cartridge. The result is what may very well be the best all-around .44 cartridge made for general use today.

SIG sent me this statement on their excellent ammo:

“Sig Sauer V-Crown Revolver products are fully compatible with all known Revolvers, Bolt Action Rifles, and Lever Action Rifles in a given caliber. However, terminal ballistics are optimized for the lower kinetic energy levels that are inherent in shorter barrel platforms. For 44 S&W SPL and 44 Rem Mag this means barrels in the 2.5” to 5.0” range. This is not to say that terminal ballistic performance may not be excellent with some longer barrel platforms just that this was not the design intent of the product.”

Ammunition is available in 20 round boxes for an MSRP of $30.00 on SIG’s website (about $23 at online retailers).

Of interest to me is the overall length of this cartridge. I’m very much an ‘ammo guy’, probably more so than I am a ‘gun guy’, and have played around with loading my .38 Special cartridges, among others, longer than standard to see what happens. SIG loaded these rounds to about the same overall length as the slightly longer .44 Magnum, which no doubt helps this round with reliable cycling in a bolt or lever action, as well as aiding in accuracy in a revolver. The individual rounds also just look so cool.

Accuracy

I tested this load in a Smith & Wesson Model 69. This is a relatively new revolver chambered in .44 Magnum, although it is also able to fire .44 Special. I have put this gun through rigorous testing and have a very good impression of what it is able to do. I believe that the gun is best with .44 Special and light .44 Magnum loads, as the revolver lacks the mass to make it comfortable and controllable with anything on the upper end of the power spectrum.

This gun was fired with the SIG load at a distance of 25 yards for accuracy off the bench. I achieved five-shot groups measuring an average of 2.5”. This was great performance considering the short barrel and sight radius. Close range groups were much tighter.

Velocity for this load was tested over my Oehler 35P chronograph at a distance of five feet from the muzzle. Average velocity was 798fps.

Ballistic Performance

I received a 10% FBI gel block from Clear Ballistics for this section of my testing. The rounds were fired into the gel at a self-defense distance of twenty feet.

The mild recoil would make you think that this round would simply bounce off a bad guy, but that is hardly the case. Penetration in bare gel was deep, with rounds passing completely through while expanding at a depth of about 3”. The expanded bullets were wide, creating permanent wound channels about .55” wide.

Penetration through standard fabric, denim, and leather was also great, although in some of the heaviest layers and materials the bullets slightly deformed, but still expanded. Penetration depth was 14-16” in these conditions, with many bullets still passing completely through.

Wounding Capacity

This round is not at all a speed-demon in terms of muzzle velocity. In fact, the V-Crown bullet types are hardly fast at all by comparison to most others out there in common use. If speed were the only factor, it wouldn’t seem all that great. If mass was all that we were concerned with, the .45 ACP would have it beat handily.

What SIG’s .44 Special load has is a unique combination of bullet technology, engineering, and outside-the-box thinking. Despite everything it has going against it in terms of abstract numbers, the load is easily on par with any self-defense round out there.  The slug has a nice, large hollow point main cavity and as you can see, it expands nicely with maximum weight retention.  While it doesn’t have quite the weight of the .45 ACP slugs, it still has sizeable muzzle energy.

In terms of penetration and expansion, the round did extremely well showing consistent, near optimal expansion. I was very pleased with it and like that it always penetrated deeply, but didn’t over-penetrate to excess.

Overall

The combination of this load and the Model 69 is hard to beat for a carry revolver. For a daily carry load, the .44 Special is just about perfect, offering high bullet weight, low recoil, and great terminal performance. I think that what SIG did here was completely unexpected and a very interesting move for this great SIG V-Crown cartridge. While not as powerful as .44 Magnum, it is certainly more feasible for normal use.

Ratings (out of five stars):

Accuracy: * * * * *
Considering the short barrel length of the Model 69, this load generated excellent accuracy at all ranges it was tested. I was very pleased with it.

Handling: * * * * *
Recoil was low and easy and follow-up shots were fast. The smooth trigger of the Model 69 was a great compliment to this easy-shooting load.

Reliability: * * * * *
No issues here. Every round went off just as advertised.

Terminal Performance: * * * * *
These big, slow moving bullets do tremendous work in tissue and offer a remarkable degree of penetration and uniform expansion with minimal recoil.

Overall: * * * * *
The .44 Special is a round that has ebbed and flowed in popularity since its introduction. While it struggles for acceptance today against nearly every other common carry cartridge, it still maintains a solid follower base. Thanks to surprising innovations like those from SIG, it’s guaranteed to stick around well into this century.

 

comments

  1. avatar tdiinva says:

    The V-Crown I looked at in detail was the 10mm. It worked fine in bare gel but failed the heavy denim test. So either they have improved the design or performance varies with caliber.

    1. avatar Jeff in CO says:

      I think the variance in calibers is the key. Several tests through 4-layers of IWBA heavy denim out of a short barrel 9mm failed to perform reliably.

      I think this goes to show that we still need to be extremely discerning in our carry load and take in factors such as barrel lengths. What performs well in a service pistol won’t necessarily perform well in a subcompact.

      1. avatar John says:

        Are these Vcrowns available in +P and +P+? It could be the solution for shorter barrels.

        1. avatar kahlil says:

          I’ve only ever seen the +P in .38 spcl from Sig. My opinion is that if you need +p out of a .44 you might as well go for the .44 mag. I consider myself lucky I’ve never used any of my firearms defensively but I am happy with the Sig ammo. It has feed reliably in my Berettas and the 38/357 rounds are great in a revolver. I’ve actually stopped carrying .357 mag for the time being in favor of the .38 spl +p load (2″ snubby).
          https://www.sigsauer.com/store/ammunition/defensive.html

          Retail I can get .40, .45 Colt, .357, or .38 +P between $15-20 a box, I’ve never seen stores sell for more than $24 on any of the common calibers.

          correction, they also do .38 Super in +p

      2. avatar tdiinva says:

        10mm test was from a G20. Barrel length was not an issue.

  2. avatar possum says:

    So being longer the V crowns probably wouldn’t work in a Charter Arms44 or other handguns chambered specifically for .44 SPC. I find it odd that Sig developed this for what is otherwise an obsolete cartridge. However I’m seeing a trend in company’s pushing DA revolvers. In my tin hat world I’m thinking inside information on a semi-automatics ban, or perhaps ammo capacity restrictions. Truth be told if I was limited to six cartridges it would be DA revolvers for me. .44 spc vs. .45 auto is not that big a difference if you boost the velocity a bit on the .44, which is easily done. Back in the day the .44 special used to be the Big Dog

    1. avatar kahlil says:

      They also produce .45 Colt V Crown that is a joy to shoot in a lever gun. I assume it is for folks carrying Judges and Governors around.

    2. avatar tdiinva says:

      Put away your tinfoil hat. Sig is filling a niche that nobody else wants.

      1. avatar possum says:

        Well I do like my .44 spc, and the availability and ammo choices for it does suck, that’s for sure. I can’t see the increased length of the cartridge however, seems to me that it would tie up the cylinder on a .44 spc only firearm. If that is the case it makes this cartridge .44 spc for use in Magnum actions only. ?????

    3. avatar El Sid says:

      The SAAMI overall length for both Special and Magnum cartridges are the same.
      Reviews say it fits the Bulldog just fine.

      1. avatar possum says:

        I was going off on that some 320gr .429 caliber bullets tie up the cylinder of my Blackhawk and don’t on the Redhawk. I should have read a little closer. It’s been a bad hair day for me, lol

  3. avatar Mike. says:

    I have both .44 special and .38 special short barrel revolvers. Is there any benefit in carrying the .44?
    I carry a Glock 26 most of the time

    1. avatar possum says:

      Leroy Brown, Lester Moore, .44 special is cool daddy oh

      1. avatar Jeff in CO says:

        I’m more of a 650 mm Creedmoor Special person myself… 😛

  4. avatar raptor jesus says:

    GP100 > Model 69

  5. avatar TP says:

    More 44spl offerings the better.

  6. avatar tsbhoa.p.jr says:

    these would be good for shooting ford sedans. but do they make an m grand?

  7. avatar El Duderino says:

    Neat, but they should just brand this with the Charter Arms logo.

    Serious .44Spl guns like the Ruger GP100 and the S&W 624 are better served with a defensive load that generates more than 213 ft-lbs of muzzle energy.

    If you’re carrying a .44 Magnum like the S&W 69 for self defense, I highly recommend the Cor-Bon 165gr JHP load that makes about 1300fps from a 4″ barrel. Recoil is somewhere between a .357 and .41 Magnum because, well, that’s about where it’s at ballistically.

    1. avatar tdiinva says:

      Is that you Mr. Callahan?

      1. avatar El Duderino says:

        I think Dirty Harry was quoted as saying he loaded his up with .44 Specials.

        The old 246gr LRN would be an absolute pussycat from a 6-1/2″ 29.

        That Cor-Bon load is very controllable with an all-steel gun. It might even be great with the 329PD, though also might be an erosion problem a la the 110gr .357 Hi-Vels.

    2. avatar kahlil says:

      Sig’s own .45 Colt v crown is more powerful than the 44 special

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

button to share on facebook
button to tweet
button to share via email