Revolvers made by Dance are some of the most distinctive guns to come out of the south. While they are copied from the Colt Dragoon, they differ in a very important aspect of appearance. Dance revolvers lack a recoil shield on both sides of the gun, giving their frame a very flat look. Made in .36 and .44 caliber, both models lack recoil shields.
James Henry Dance and his brothers were descended from a color bearer who served directly under General George Washington. Not long before the Civil War, James left home in Alabama and headed to Texas. A year later, his three brothers and two sisters joined him, where they purchased 900 acres and opened a large-scale blacksmith shop.
Production on revolvers began in 1862 in East Columbia, Texas, after Governor Lubbock received a letter signed by 26 prominent citizens of the city. Because revolvers were in such high demand, Governor Lubbock exempted Dance factory workers from military service. He felt that they served a greater purpose in making guns for fighting than actually fighting themselves.
Many contemporaries believed the Dance revolvers to be a superior design. In September 1862, The Houston Tri-Weekly Telegraph called the guns “superior to Colt’s best” in one of their columns.
By 1863, Union forces became aware of the Dance factory and it quickly became a target. The company decided to relocate a few miles away to avoid being shelled by gun boats on the Brazos River. Upon relocation, the factory was supposed to pick up where they left off and keep making revolvers. For one reason or another, production never resumed.
The exact number of J.H. Dance & Brothers revolvers made is unknown; estimates put it somewhere between 325 and 500. The majority were made in .44 caliber, making the smaller .36 caliber models rarer than their larger counterparts. One should exercise extreme caution when considering purchase of a supposed-original Dance revolver, especially the rarer 36-caliber version; many fakes have been made with great ease by removing the recoil shield on Colt revolvers.
(Firearm courtesy of NRA Museums)
Logan Metesh is a firearms historian and consultant who runs High Caliber History LLC. Click here for a free 3-page download with tips about caring for your antique and collectible firearms.