Cameras, c Nick Leghorn

Shooting things is awesome, and tons of fun. But what’s the point in enjoying your freedoms here in the United States if you can’t record it, share it with your coworkers in Australia, and laugh maniacally as they become increasingly jealous? There are a ton of consumer cameras on the market these days that look to give you the ability to record your various and sundry sporting activities, but which is tops for the shooting sports? I picked out two of the best — the GoPro Hero 3 and Contour ROAM2 — and took them to the range to test them out . . .

Cameras are becoming more and more commonplace on the range, especially at shooting competitions. Looking cool seems to be half the sport these days. Not that I’m particularly innocent of that criticism, I just happen to be better at looking awesome than most.

As I’m ramping up for the Team FNH USA competition season, I’m looking into which cameras will give me the most bang for my buck. And by that I mean not only the best video quality, but the least likely to get in the way during a stage and won’t detract from my natural cool factor.

In terms of video quality, right off the bat there’s a clear winner. Here’s some test footage I took with each camera:

The GoPro Hero 3 was designed from the ground up to be a cinema quality camera in a small package. It has a larger digital sensor, a better microphone and much more variety in resolution and frame rate settings. In short, its the Swiss Army Knife of tiny cameras. That also means that it has more menus, bells, whistles and knobs than you can shake a stick at. Not necessarily something ready to go right out of the box.

The Contour ROAM 2, on the other hand, does 1080p at 30 frames per second tops. That’s half the speed of the Hero 3. But the Contour also clocks in at half the price of the Black edition Hero 3 (used for this review, and just about all of my video needs). The Hero 3 Black runs about $400, while the Contour is only $200. It’s easier to use, has very simple controls and comes with a laser guide for making sure the camera is level. There are other benefits as well to the sleeker and cheaper camera.

P1230892

Both of these cameras have headband mounts available from the manufacturer, which lets you give viewers a first person perspective of the action. However, the way they mount is drastically different.

P1230899

The GoPro Hero 3 mounts directly to the front of your forehead, which gives the best perspective for the camera but (A) can get in the way of things and (B) makes you look like a doofus. It also means you can’t really wear a hat, which can be annoying when it’s sunny outside.

P1230904

The Contour, on the other hand, mounts to the side of your head. It stays out of your way, and lets you keep your hat on. The view isn’t quite as good as with the GoPro, but it gets the job done.

P1230919

Speaking of mounts, that’s another place where the Contour shines. The GoPro comes with a couple mounting options, and there are more available through various retailers, but their scope is rather limited. There’s a handlebar mount, a suction cup mount, and then a slew of sticky mounts, and that’s it. The Contour, though, comes with more types of mounts than the GoPro. Point and case: the Controur has a Picatinny mount you can buy directly from their web store. The best the GoPro has available is an aftermarket mount from Strikemark that I’ve already had to slice off of a firearm when the screw seized in the mount.

P1230923

Just like the head mount, the Contour camera’s sleek design keeps it close to the rail and doesn’t stick out to the side much. If you’re planning on running a camera mounted in this fashion, the Contour is definitely the way to go.

P1230975

The GoPro, on the other hand, sticks way the hell out there taking up valuable space and possibly getting in the way of your shooting. Again, due to its design, this is about the best you’re gonna get. It gives a superior view, but it also gets in the way.

Before we wrap up the discussion, I want to talk about battery life. With the Contour, I think I’ve had to charge it twice. When you flip the switch to start recording, that’s when everything turns on. Its nice and saves battery life, meaning you can usually throw it in a bag and forget about it for a while. With the GoPro, I have to charge it before every competition (as the battery will have inevitably run down) and it doesn’t last very long when you’re recording video. I’ve been reduced to bringing spare batteries for the thing so I can swap them when they run flat.

In short, the Contour is better designed in terms of battery life.

P1230880

So, which is best? Well, it depends.

If you just need a camera to record videos to show your friends and are looking for a convenient and lightweight solution, then the Contour ROAM 2 is pick. The lower price combined with its ease of use makes it ideal for those who just want to be able to share their experiences with friends. There’s also a version that has GPS and can live stream for the same price as the GoPro.

However, if you really need cinema quality video of your competitions, or you happen to like/need tons of bells and whistles, then the Hero 3 is the right choice. It’s a little more awkward to use and doesn’t always fit into the places you want it to go, but with a little ingenuity you can always get that perfect shot. It also comes with a nifty feature that lets you control the camera via a remote or with your smart phone, but its buggy and doesn’t always work.

Personally, the Hero 3 is my favorite. Even though its big and bulky and the battery life sucks, the variety it gives you in terms of frame rate and resolution more than make up for the shortcomings. The Contour gets the job done, but the Hero gets it done right.

Recommended For You

15 Responses to GoPro Hero 3 v. Contour ROAM 2: Firearms Footage Showdown

  1. Interesting comments. We have similar conclusions. I have both cameras as well which I am going to start using on my next set of DVDs. I purchased the Contour with the longer lens and custom built a mount to sit it on the top of my AR rail looking through the front site. This gives me a nice shooter’s perspective of the target.

    I found that I prefer the POV of the Hero mounted on the forehead. Gives a more natural perspective compared to the Contour on the side.

  2. I watched the two comparison videos and frankly I had a hard time noticing much difference while watching the video on my Mac laptop. The resolution at 720 on YouTube seemed about the same. Sound? GoPro was maybe a bit better.

    But…it seemed to me that you were more accurate while shooting with GoPro.

    🙂

  3. The go pro mounted on be rifle reminded me of one of those Aliens marines and their tracking device.

    Thanks for the review

  4. you show the waterproof case on the gopro even though you are not using it underwater. gopro has a mount called “the frame” which is a basic black plastic frame around the unit with an open front and rear. better video quality and MUCH better sound quality with the mic being in open air.

    • It is correct but we must consider that Contour Roam2 is waterproof without any case. When using GoPro without case the possibilities of being harmed or “watered” are big!! So Nick took the decission of comparing the cams in the same conditions of protection.

  5. Great review. I’ve had GoPro’s in the past and love them, but for firearm related purposes, I think the Contour is a good choice. Esp with the cheaper price tag.

  6. Personally I purchased the Replay XD camera based on your last review online with them. Since I have owned the camera, I have had nearly every person on the range either ask me about it, or pick one up themselves. The Contour camera is crap! My son had one for his snowmobile but made the switch to a Replay too. I think a more fair review would of been to put a Replay VS GO Pro VS Contour and Sony against each other. Seems like your content is more in favors rather that true quality that is available, I just dont see how these cameras can top that last review and not even mention it… http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2013/02/chris-dumm/gear-review-replay-xd720-sports-cam/

  7. Hey Nick. Interesting point about the Contour’s sleekness playing a role, though I agree the Hero trumps it in terms of quality. Maybe going outside the lines a bit with the mounts would solve the bulk issues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *