Gun Review: Ruger LCR .357 Revolver

80 responses

  1. avatar
    Nick Leghorn
    September 8, 2011

    I’ve actually been looking at the LCR for a “pocket carry” pistol, for those times when an IWB would stick out like a sore thumb. How easy is this to keep in a pocket? Does it make much of a bulge?

    (Nice review, BTW)

    • avatar
      Gus
      September 8, 2011

      My .38 LCR rides well in a regular pair of cargoes or khakis. Not very noticeable at all. Last Saturday I pocketed mine and set out on some errands. I ended up cutting the grass and crawling around in the attic to run some wire without a thought on the weapon. However, It’s a little thick to be comfortable in a boot, if you ever carry that way.

    • avatar
      Ryan Finn
      September 8, 2011

      Thanks Nick. As long as I’m wearing appropriate pants, the LCR has no problem going into a pocket. The one thing that hinders it in that respect is that if your pants are a wee bit tight then the grip does tend to stand out a little due to its size. However, Ruger does have boot grips for the LCR that are much smaller and still have the Hogue Tamer insert and a good pocket holster can mitigate some of that also.

    • avatar
      Gary
      March 8, 2014

      I have owned the Ruger LCR 357 for a few years now and can honestly say it is the easiest gun to conceal carry that I have. I usually carry it in my inner jacket pocket but sometimes carry it in my pants pocket. It is small enough that it does not show any indications that I’m carrying a gun. The recoil is very easy shooting 357 loads. I prefer this gun for night time protection due to the size and non reflective finish on the gun also there is no slide to rack as with the 1911′s that I own. I also like the fact that I don’t have to worry about a possible jam. Pretty much the original point and click that always works when needed.

  2. avatar
    Tim McNabb
    September 8, 2011

    I was wondering about this new Ruger since I saw it in the shop. It looks wicked awesome. Glad it is a good shooter.

    Excellent review – posted to our Facebook page

    http://www.facebook.com/pages/Mid-America-Arms/246974128676277?sk=wall

  3. avatar
    Big John
    September 8, 2011

    Epithets, Ryan. He was only hurling epitaphs if he was hucking gravestones. Great review, though.

    • avatar
      E. Zach Lee-Wright
      September 12, 2011

      Good catch. Watch out for flying tombstones!

      Good review, Ryan. When these first came out my local dealer offered me the chance to play with one that had not been picked up by its proper owner yet. I declined. I just was not interested or impressed with the idea of a plastic revolver. This review however is why I like TTAG and now I have a need to shoot this thing.

  4. avatar
    The Cabinet Man
    September 8, 2011

    Grammar nazi alert!

    I think you meant ‘epithets’ instead of ‘epitaphs’…

    TCM

    • avatar
      Robert Farago
      September 8, 2011

      Text amended.

  5. avatar
    Gus
    September 8, 2011

    I love my .38 LCR. I’ve got a few snubbie .38s to compare it to, including a smith 442. The LCR is definitely my pick of the bunch. Can’t wait to grab one in .357 after this review. I’ll likely trade or sell the 442 to get it.

  6. avatar
    Robert Farago
    September 8, 2011

    Sam shoots her Smith & Wesson more accurately when it’s loaded with .357s than .38s. I also wonder what that’s all about . . .

    Heads-up: I’m shooting the Smith & Wesson Model 60 Professional stainless steel snub-nosed .357 (with night sights) today. I’ll review it and then send it to you for a comparo.

    • avatar
      Ralph
      September 8, 2011

      I’ve always believed that .357 rounds were more accurate than .38 Spls. when fired from 2″ snubbies. .38s seem to need a 4″ barrel or longer to reach their potential. I don’t know why.

      • avatar
        Travis Leibold
        September 8, 2011

        Theory: Shooters subconciously grip the gun more rigidly in anticipation of the 357 and more lackidasicly (sp) for the 38s.

      • avatar
        Scott.A
        September 9, 2011

        But doesn’t gripping a gun more rigidly hurt your aim? I notice when I grip harder I shoot low left cause of a bad trigger pull

    • avatar
      Gossven
      September 8, 2011

      Are the bullets loaded into factory .357 loads the same as factory .38 loads. If they have a longer bearing surface wouldn’t that provide them with better accuracy? Also on a weapon with fixed sights your elevation would most likely be off as well since .357 is moving significantly faster than .38.

  7. avatar
    John
    September 8, 2011

    I’ve had a .38 version for a year now. Just crossed the 1500 round mark with it on Labor Day. It’s my EDC, and I’ve had no problems with it. Rides in the front pocket of my jeans and looks like a wallet when using a DeSantis Nemesis holster. Highly recommended.

  8. avatar
    RecoveringAtheist
    September 8, 2011

    I only have one poly based weapon and that is a Ruger PC9 9mm carbine that I really, really love. Looks like Ruger will be selling me my first poly handgun as well.

  9. avatar
    William C. Montgomery
    September 8, 2011

    I’m in love.

    (I didn’t think I’d ever say that about an ugly snubbie.)

    Thanks for the review.

  10. avatar
    Ralph
    September 8, 2011

    Nice, Ryan. It seemed from the viddies that .357s caused only marginally more muzzle flip than .38s. That’s amazing.

    • avatar
      Ryan Finn
      September 8, 2011

      Yea it was definitely a welcome surprise.

  11. avatar
    Jarhead1982
    September 9, 2011

    Load the .357 to hot 9mm specifications with 158 gr JHP and you have a reduced recoil thumper that you can easily keep all 5 shots rapid fire in a circle the spread of your hand at 10 yards while getting almost double the ballistic performance of .38 P Plus that many prefer to use as a carry load.

    And yes, the trigger pull really is as good as he states and no doubt does contribute to this accuracy.

  12. avatar
    Gunnutmegger
    September 9, 2011

    The Hogue grips are great for shooting, but not so great for concealing. They tend to grab at clothes and increase the likelihood of printing-through.

    And they make it more difficult to grip & draw from a pocket holster.

    I prefer wood (or other non-grabby) materials for grips when I carry a revolver.

  13. avatar
    MALTHUS
    September 12, 2011

    Just when it looked like the revolver was destined to share the fate of vinyl records and vacuum tubes, Ruger engineers achieve a break-through design. Even the most diehard J-frame fans will now be forced to admit that the little .357 LCR is first among equals.

  14. avatar
    supton
    September 12, 2011

    I traded my 38spl LCR in for the 357 version, as I found the 38spl version to have just too much recoil. Although, to be fair, it was my only centerfire firearm (although I did pick up a 3″ SP101 at the same time). Much more pleasant to shoot, although I do notice it much more on pocket carry. Eh, need to shoot what one carries.

    I’m not sure which one I prefer: the SP101 or the LCR. The LCR definatly has more recoil. But the trigger is simply so much better. Neither gun is a real plinker, so, hate to say it: but I think the LCR is my preferred gun.

    If Ruger were to make a 20 or 22oz 6 round 3″ revolver with the LCR trigger I might well just buy it on the spot. Heck, even at the 26oz weight of the SP101 I’d buy it–light recoil, brilliant trigger, good balance. Who would need SA with a DA trigger like this?

  15. avatar
    1776
    September 15, 2011

    Purchased a SP-101 .38 snubby for home defense. Was a wee bit heavy for the bride.
    Took my gunshop owner’s advice & traded it in for this .357 LCR.
    Am delighted with its accuracy and portability.

  16. avatar
    Doug
    September 23, 2011

    NICE review, I just bought the LCR 357 today even over the great S&W 442 which was my other top choice and what I had bought my wife, and I love. This gun has a much more refined modern design, the trigger and feel of the gun is superior to the smith. The trigger is one of the best I’ve ever felt. I mean revolutionary good for a gun in this price and size. The hogue grips very nice. I shot more accurate with 38 and my groups were tighter than the review even at 30-35 feet but the 357 is one hell of a bang. The cylinder and mechanics are super fine, and in many ways this gun could be superior to the Smith in many ways and about EQUAL when you average it all out. I bought the S&W bodyguard 380 the day before and just dont like it. I’d like the CT laser but the price is bordering on a ripoff at 299.00 and the grip is not even close to the stock one in comfort and feel. I have 100% confidence this is going to be a much more accurate shooter than the Smith 442 due to just the trigger alone. This trigger is easily 30% easier, smoother and shorter stroke. I just compared again to the 442 and WOW what an ergo difference. This one is just very slightly more concealable for some reason. Vanishes…. I also think the cylinder to barrel mating is tighter and more refined.

  17. avatar
    ChaZ
    September 24, 2011

    Super fun gun. Just shot .357′s and .38′s through it today… I had great groupings with the .38, lots of fun. The .357 kicked like crazy, actually painful. (only shot 10 of the .357 cuz my hand hurt.) Maybe I was tensing up too much.
    I will still load .357′s for concealed carry, but will plink w/ the .38′s.

  18. avatar
    John
    October 28, 2011

    Picked up a Ruger LCR .357 today and cannot wait to shoot it. It feels great and it is a quality made revolver. Trying to find some Hornady Critical Defense .357 ammo for it this week.

  19. avatar
    Dave
    November 19, 2011

    Nice one! A must have for me and a great review!

  20. avatar
    steve lamanen
    December 10, 2011

    Great review of the Ruger LCR… the Hogue Grips have a gel insert, very clever… I just finished field testing the new IWB Comfort Carry holster design from signatureholsters.com. I like the way the Ruger design team changed the handle design geometry. The LCR also makes for a nice front pocket gun, if you find front pocket carry comfortable… Great review Ryan!

  21. avatar
    Chris
    January 2, 2012

    Thanks guys for the great reviews of the Ruger LCR 357. As soon as I collect my pennies, I’ll be headed down to pick one up. I’ve had a Ruger Security Six since 1980 and wouldn’t trade it for anything. Ruger makes a great product and stands by their guns. Happy New Year !!

  22. avatar
    John
    January 16, 2012

    WANT

  23. avatar
    Dad
    January 16, 2012

    I have one, I like it more than any other snubbie I have ever shot. The sights leave something to be desired and I will be replacing the front sight with either an XS big dot or trijicon in the near future. Make no mistake though, with full power .357 loads it is not any fun………….tolerable, but not fun.

  24. avatar
    george poulos
    January 23, 2012

    I also was never a big fan of magnum snubs, Had a nickel plated s&w model 19 years ago that shot a 5 foot ball of flame with factory magnum loads. I recently gave my 40 year old Colt det. special to my oldest son as a family heirloom so it needed to be replaced. The choice was the LCR .357. Just bought it after Christmas and went right to the range. Shot very well ,but it would not eject spent magnum casings. Had to extract them. thank god I had my Leatherman tool with me. Wondering if I am the only person with this issue?

  25. avatar
    bill
    January 24, 2012

    Great write up….looks like ruger is getting more of my money. Until recently a compact or snubby had no use in my state of residence as it was open carry only and sporting use required 6″ muzzle to firing pin. Now that Wisconsin has a decent governor for the moment and granted us concealed carry and castle laws to actually defend ones self and property, my interest is peaked and your review sealed the deal.
    Thank-you also for dispelling some of the mythical recoil often touted in gun reviews. As gun owners It’s our duty to take newbies out to the range and let them experience the fun we have. This creates more voters on our side of the fence by revealing the misinformation of lamestream media first hand. However, our job is made more difficult by members of our own crowd instilling irrational fear of the discomfort of discharging firearms. It’s those rumors that kept an inherited 30-06 in my safe for many years. When I finally got up the courage I realised it was nothing and have since found 300 wby mag to be nothing more either. Now days 200+ rds of 308 are common in an afternoon for me, just resting the barrel for cool down while I shoot other firearms. 357 mag isn’t anything to be afraid of but often people shy away because all the hoopla, they envision themselves on their butt with a broken wrist and a bloody nose. When I first bought one I thought I’d use 38 ammo mostly and only have 357 in it for when it’s needed. After shooting it, all I buy is 357 as I don’t notice any recoil with either rd.
    I’m glad you conveyed the enjoyment of extended tactical range visits, they make promotion of our passion way easier as a bench and paper circles get old fast. Zombies and steels at undefined distances make hours and ammo vaporize, and increase your proficiency and fun in multitudes.

  26. avatar
    Tim
    February 4, 2012

    I just took my new lcr 357 out for a test run and I have to say that I really liked it. It packs one hell of a punch and I would recommend that if you are practicing to definitely wear good eye protection. The blow back tends to smack you upside the face. I like to shoot my guns without eye protection initially to see how they perform, especially since when I am in the field with them, I need to know what to expect. I replaced the front sight with an xs tritium front sight and I like it. Your sight picture changes and learning the hold will take some practice. This is due partl because the xs sight is taller than the stock sight, therefore your front dot is disected by the rear groove. The gun was semi accurate at 10 yards, but I will take the blame for that. I messed around with the trigger pull a bit and found m dads old way of a slow and smooth trigger pull will not work for me on this gun. The action is very long and any small disturbance in the trigger pull sent rounds flying. I saw a show on the s&w body guard 380 and the instructors recommended a more deliberat pull due to the heavier trigger pull. I tried that out and found myself grouping much tighter and even grouping reasonably at 25 yards. I also did this with rapid fire and grouped better than “taking my time”. This is a great attribute for personal defense, which is why I got this gun. To answer George’s question, to get a clean extraction from your cylinder, you need to rack the ejector pretty good to clear the spent brass. If there was a flaw to this gun, this would be it. All in all I am very happy with my choice, the gun is powerful, easy to carry, and for the money it is a steal for a firearm of this quality.

    • avatar
      Ben Dover
      March 19, 2012

      Do your self a favor, don’t rack the ejection rod. Just lubricate it good with
      a teflon spray. Let the gun break in and it should work fine. Once the gun
      gets warmed up the cartridges should almost fall out. The aluminum
      cartridges may be a little tighter, but not enough to have to use anything
      other than the palm of your hand to eject.

  27. avatar
    dan
    February 15, 2012

    just bought one i’m really hoping to get it out asap!

  28. avatar
    Rod Bowlin
    March 18, 2012

    I love this gun. Its powerful and accurate. I’m not an expert with firearms but I haven’t missed with this baby yet. First 357 round caught me by surprise. There is a kick although manageable. Once I got use to it not a problem. I definately think this is a must buy if you carry concealed. I’ve retired my Glock 22 to home protection only.

  29. avatar
    Ben Dover
    March 19, 2012

    Great little gun but it has it’s peculiarities about ammo. In the 400 + rounds since
    purchase, I have experimented with many different types of ammo. This gun hates
    125gr. 38cal. ammo, especially flat or JSP target rounds. It’s accuracy drops off
    quickly after about 25 feet. The only 125gr. that I had any luck with was the
    Winchester DPX-1 bonded JHP Hydo Shok 357mag. It was still viable at 50 feet
    but the grouping suffered. The best results I achieved was with 158gr. JHP in either
    38cal. special +P and 357mag. Even the CCI Blazer 158gr. 357mag JHP, with the
    aluminum casings, shot well. These were the best economical target rounds. The
    lower power did seem to matter much.

  30. avatar
    C H
    March 27, 2012

    Gave up after a few weeks? It takes YEARS to master the 5 shot snubby.

  31. avatar
    Ryan1Dog
    April 9, 2012

    I’ve looked through all the snubs on the market. This seems to be the best. The Smith and Wesson trigger pull is absolutely ridiculous with an eleven pound trigger pull and even if you get the partially concealed hammer, to pull takes a two hand approach. The Taurus is slightly better trigger pull, but still. The LCR has an unbelievably smooth trigger pull as the article says, and smooth and steady will stack the rounds if that’s what you want.
    As far as the recoil of the 357, I guess I’m used to my hunting pistol. Referring to the man card, shoot my S&W 460 then come back and say the recoil on LCR 357 is bad. My 460 makes the LCR feel like a derringer.
    This is one fantastic revolver and as far as concealed, powerful protection, it doesn’t get any better than this pistol.

    • avatar
      Bradley Ballard
      July 3, 2013

      I just purchased a LCR 357.
      Hoping what said about it is true.
      You like it appearantly.
      Bradley

  32. avatar
    Wiebelhaus
    May 29, 2012

    I’m late to the party but I must say this revolver is my favorite gun ever now but I’m no expert or anything, just a regular dude who can pick this revolver up and hit the target at surprising distances every time for a snub nose.

    • avatar
      Dave Rosen
      October 21, 2013

      Shoot lilke you are now and enjoy the gun. Practice with that one gun you may carry and learn it by heart.
      The LCR in .357 is a fine carry gun with the best trigger feel I’ve ever experienced except for the Colt Python in the safe.
      Good luck shooting, have fun and may God bless the citizens of the United States.

  33. avatar
    Mike P
    May 30, 2012

    In my opinion, the Ruger LCR in 357 is the perfect carry piece, for the following reasons:

    It’s a .357. Recoil is stiff, but not that bad.

    It fits in the front or rear pocket of jeans, khakis, cargo shorts, whatever.

    The trigger is the best double action trigger I’ve ever felt. Period.

    I’ve put about 500 rounds through it without anything even close to a misfire.

    And best of all: “POINTABILITY!!!” The gun practically aims itself!

    Highly recommended.

  34. avatar
    Robert
    July 26, 2012

    I own the LCR 357, but have never pushed 357s thru it. Why? After I bought it, I was reviewing some google vids. This guy had loaded the LCR with alternating rounds of 38s, +Ps and 357, (I’m not sure what order) and handed it to a woman (at the range). She had no idea what was loaded, where. She fired the first shot and flinched a little. The recoil of the 2nd round nearly took her head off.

    I felt his stunt was totally cruel, and potentially dangerous. I also felt, why do I want to load 357s if they have that kind of recoil!? Needless to say, I glad I ran across your video. I will be picking up a box, or two for some long-overdue range time….

  35. avatar
    CaptD
    August 4, 2012

    I too have one of these great pistols. I found the one great drawback to concealed carry was the rubber grip. Perfect for taming the recoil, but way too sticky to clothing. The fix-get a new grip-they are out there if you look hard enough. I got what’s called the CIA grip. It’s like the boot grip but smooth wood. Awesome. Cost a lot too. I think I got it from Eagle grips(online). Along with a big dot front sight and a great holster from Simply Rugged, this thing will be with me forever.

    • avatar
      Mike P
      August 31, 2012

      I’m assuming you carry with 357s. How is the recoil with the wooden grip? In other words, I’ve been wondering how much difference the Houge tamer grip makes.

  36. avatar
    Klaus Schiff
    September 14, 2012

    Nice to read it.

  37. avatar
    bill35738
    September 19, 2012

    Heres a little trick I picked up somewhere on the internet for capt D drawback of the rubber grip. I didnt like the way it grabbed on to shirt but I loved the way it ft my hand and helped with recoil with 357. I tried the boot-grip from ruger,but its a little smaller and doesnt have the finger groves on the front, I just couldnt get used to it. Like I said somewhere on the internet this guy said the way to stop the grippeyness on rubber grips is to wipe the grip down with lighter fluid and let dry over night. then paint the whole grip with clear satin polyurethane an let it dry overnight. I did it with mine and it works great even for pocket carry

  38. avatar
    DaveMod
    October 3, 2012

    I have this gun, I hate it and would not trust my life on it (for that is why we carry a firearm is it not?) I am a Cali CCW holder and while it is compact, packs a .357 punch and IS highly concealable, I will not carry it and here’s why. First and foremost is the trigger pull. Yes it is smooth but you cannot pre-load the trigger reliably. There is not a disernable click when removing the slack. Secondly since it only carries 5 shots and reloading is important, the cylinder release sucks. It is sticky and unreliable. and there are no speedloaders available for it as yet. Small and cute but don’t bet your life on it…………………

    • avatar
      Jack James
      October 4, 2012

      But is it accurate and go bang everytime you squeeze the trigger ?

    • avatar
      Mike P
      October 19, 2012

      To each his own, but I don’t have any problem pre-loading the trigger…when the cylinder stops turning, I stop pulling the trigger, until I’m ready for the gun to fire. Also, I personally have not had any trouble with the cylinder release. No speed loaders? That might still be true. Small and cute? It ain’t cute!

  39. avatar
    Caligula
    November 29, 2012

    I Love this gun! The trigger is much lighter and smoother than my SW J frame that has been dry fired a few thousand times with snap caps. The Factory supplied grips are also much better than the J frame factory grips , and fit my XXL hands perfectly. Even hot Gold Dot .357 125 grain HP’s are controllable. They still sting my hand, but I wouldn’t expect anything less from such a hot load in a 17 oz revolver.

  40. avatar
    doug rebo
    December 21, 2012

    great gun. one correction. the frame is not steel. it is anodized aluminum. look at the manual in the frame finish touch-up section.

    • avatar
      Matt
      February 21, 2014

      Late to the party but need to correct this. The .357 version uses a stainless steel frame. The .38 Special version uses aluminum. Hence the reason the .357 version is about 3.5 oz heavier.

  41. avatar
    Bill
    December 28, 2012

    Could I get some ammo sugestions?
    I just purchased a LCR .357 for the purpose of back country black bear spray. I carried a .44 in the past but needed a lighter gun.
    Also, an ammo recommendation for accurate .38 plinking.
    Thanks

    • avatar
      Mountaintac
      December 30, 2012

      Bill – I also just picked up a .357 LCR for backcountry use. I use to carry a .44 loaded with Buffalo Bore Ammunition. So I decided to go with the 180 grain Buffalo Bore Ammunition with my LCR too. I don’t have numbers to give out yet, but someone else out there might. Good luck!

  42. avatar
    JMB
    December 31, 2012

    My LCR just came back from Ruger. I broke it. I bought 357 w/crimson trace and those hurt my hand shooting 357 38+p I would put Hogue Tamers on for range time and switch backand forth which is 2 to3 times a week. So Ibroke one of the grip screw holes for the C/T. While I was waiting for the LCR I could not not have a CC, so I purchased an. XDs. I know I have great CC now.

  43. avatar
    Kelly
    January 3, 2013

    Where is the safety? I recently purchased the Ruger 38 because it was smaller (I’m a petite mother of 2 under 5 years old) even though I enjoyed shooting the 357. My only concern is where is the safety at? I thought about trading my 38 up for the 357 depending on the safety? I did shoot both guns and looked at the safety prior to buying but I do not remember anymore if the 357 came with a safety switch like my hunting rifle does. Without a safety switch on the 38 like my hunting rifle, does a holster covering the trigger help?

    • avatar
      Dan
      January 22, 2013

      Safety? On a double action revolver? The closest thing I can think of is the padlock that comes with Ruger firearms.

      • avatar
        Harold
        March 23, 2013

        Is that any way to help out a new gun owner? Do you hang out at the LGS and snicker at people?

    • avatar
      Caligula
      February 10, 2013

      The safety is between your ears.

      • avatar
        Harold
        March 23, 2013

        Your unhelpful reply demonstrates what you have betwixt your ears.

    • avatar
      Harold
      March 23, 2013

      Kelly, there is no manual safety switch on this handgun. There is a key lock underneath the grip that you will see if you take out the one screw at the bottom of the grip and pull it off the gun.

  44. avatar
    Caligula
    February 9, 2013

    After less than 200 rounds, my LCR .357 locked up at the range. the trigger was stuck back and the cylinder wouldn’t turn, nor could I pop the cylinder out. I had three rounds left in a revolver that I couldn’t unload. I finally worked the trigger loose and forward, which allowed me to unload it. I tried to dry fire it unloaded and it bound up again after the first trigger pull. I’m very disappointed. This revolver is my first Ruger; I guess I’ll get to find out how good their customer service is.

  45. avatar
    Gerald Helgeson
    March 24, 2013

    Helge
    The ruger lcr truly is a fine weapon in 38 0r 357
    fits the hand & the rounds go here you put them

  46. avatar
    William W.
    April 4, 2013

    I’ve had my Ruger KLCR .357mag for over a year now. It is my EDC almost entirely-I also have a Kahr CM9 which I carry at times. I will issue one caution regarding ammo used, especially the .357mag. After buying (buy small amt. first-20rd. Box of SD carry), do the “shoot 3-4, check the 4-5th” drill. BTW, it is mentioned in the Instruction Manual of thr Ruger KLCR. I found out the hard way, when the CorBon DPX .357mag 125gr. I thought was the “Holy Grail” of ammo. locked up my Ruger. The 4th and 5th cartridges, due to the short barrel and pressure, had “backed out” enough to lock the cylinder. When I notified CorBon of this, CorBon said this is common in .357mag snubbies, and would notify production to increase the pressure on the crimping to nullify the occurrence. I now carry Hornady Critical Defence .357mag 115gr. without a problem (so far). Anyway, just a thought for all that carry this wonderful handgun to be safe, ready, and reliable when or if needed.

    • avatar
      William W.
      April 4, 2013

      Correction:I now carry Speer Gold Dot 125gr. .357mag in Ruger KLCR, with a Five Star Speedloader filled with Hornady Critical Defence 110gr .38spl+P for backup. I need to purchase more Speer GD when available in my area.

  47. avatar
    Rachel K
    April 8, 2013

    I am about to buy my first revolver. I was looking at LCR .38sp versus LCR 357 (shooting .38sp rounds) versus S&W J frame .38sp. My main concern is the recoil. I intend on keeping this at my bedside, but will also carry with me when vacationing. Any opinions or suggestions?

  48. avatar
    Dan Ess
    April 29, 2013

    I’ve been considering buying the LCR in .357. Rather surprising that Ruger has not made a .327 Magnum version of this gun. After all, they were the first to have a .327 caliber handgun. In my opinion, it would be the ultimate version of the LCR. You can shoot .32 SW Short & Long, 32HR Mag and 327 Mag. all out of the same weapon. Maybe they cannot build it strong enough to handle the pressure of the .327 round? The pressure of a .357 round is around 35,000 and a .327 runs roughly 45,000. I have an S&W model 632, it’s not as docile as the reviews led me to believe. Most people who heard and felt it (shock wave) the first few times I shot it, thought it was a .357. It’s a steel J-frame, quite nasty with the 1oo gr Federal rounds.

  49. avatar
    jimmyjames
    August 8, 2013

    Never heard of projectiles going forward in the case enough or at all to lock up a cylinder. Primers maybe. Sounds like the mighty corbons weren’t crimped at all.

  50. avatar
    Robbin
    August 8, 2013

    I have the LCR .38 with night sights. I’m encouraged by all of the positive comments on this gun. I used .38 sp 158 gr. Remington ammo and it had too much recoil for me. My hand are small. I’m working on building strength in my hands. In the mean time, is there a smaller better grip I should try? Also, which ammo would be best for range practice? I got it for home protection.

  51. avatar
    vicki
    September 25, 2013

    Can anyone comment as to recoil of 357 vs. 45acp? I have no problem with the 45 but have never shot 357. I’m a Realtor and want a Ruger lcr for when I am showing empty houses to strangers! Saw one in 357 with lazer site for $700.

    • avatar
      Robert Farago
      September 25, 2013

      A LOT more kick. .45 is a pussycat in comparison. In fact, most shooters readjust their grip after the first shot of a .357. In other words, it’s a hell of a round if one round’s all you need. If not (.e.g., you miss or the threat continues), not so much.

  52. avatar
    Tony
    January 24, 2014

    Thanks for your great review! Think I just found my new ankle back-up!

  53. avatar
    Red
    February 1, 2014

    After handling, shooting and inspecting the LCR, I decided to go with a S&W 642. The LCR is a nice gun for the price but my biggest gripe was that for a snub nose revolver that has been out since 2009 (now six years) there are only 3 types of grips available out there and they all suck (factory hogue with finger grooves, hogue bantum, and Eagle grips which are priced at over $80.) The factory grips being the worst designed grips I have ever encountered on any snub nose.

    Not everyone’s fingers fit correctly in these factory finger grooved grips. Mine don’t. This being a conceal weapon I can’t even imagine being under a stressful situation where I would need to use it and then fumble around with my fingers until I could fire the gun … totally unacceptable. Finger grooves are great for when you are at a range and you have the time to focus on getting a hold, not when you have seconds to depend on saving your life. At least S&W J frames have hundreds of grip options out there.

    My other complaint is that it feels like a very plasticky gun. It feels cheap when compared to a S&W airweight. Also again, for being a six year old model gun, why is it so hard to find any decent holsters out there for it??? More reasons why I chose a S&W.

  54. avatar
    Raymond Pitts
    February 10, 2014

    I usually carry mine crossdraw with a versacarry holster. I’ve carry with a few other holsters and it’s easily concealable but it totally disappears with the versacarry, no matter what I’m wearing. This is my go to carry when I want something reliable, decently powerful and very concealable.

  55. avatar
    Dave R.
    March 10, 2014

    I’ll give the only contrary opinoin so far. Having shot the .357 LCR and owned Ruger SP101s (and S&W Model 60s), I find the steel guns are superior in every way. They are durable and reliable. None of the odd-ball glitches that some people have encountered with the LCR. Sorry, but from an engineering standpoint a polymer, aluminum, and steel gun is just not as strong or reliable as an all steel gun of the same dimensions. Over time there will be tolerance difficulites and thermal expansion problems when dissimilar materials are mated, pinned, and sleeved.

    The SP101 with eat .357 Magum rounds all day, and your whole life, if you are up to it. The many SP101 aftermarket grips give your whole hand something to grip to tame the recoil (available in rubber, nylon or wood). The available LCR grips are all (so far) too small and uncomforatable. The SP101 can take years of shooting 38 +P and .357 with no failures, and regular 38 Special is just easy, pleasant, and fun to shoot at the range. The shorter barrel of the LCR magnifies muzzle blast. The SP101 is a simple mechanism that can be taken apart and easily tuned to have as good a trigger as the Smith or LCR. A shim kit and replacing the hammer spring will do it for $20. Light polising of the internals will make it even better. You are advised by Ruger not to take the LCR apart.

    Hey , we are only talking about 10 ounces of extra weight here. That’s not much more than the weight of the coffee you drank this morning. In a properly-designed, and supsended holster the difference is barely noticeable. But hat 10 ounces of steel makes a huge difference in controlling recoil.

    But Lots of people have poor, limp holsters, or due to body shape really need to wear wearing suspenders with a gun belt. I think that the latter is the reason so many people want a super light gun. If your belt is at an angle due to a “muffin top” your 25 ounce gun is going to tilt outward and feel uncomfortable. Losing wieght puts the belt vertical, where it needs to be.

    And if you LIKE to shoot and go to the range every few months, what are you going to enjoy shooting? A steel gun that you can shoot single action or double action, with all types of ammo, or the LCR? And would you feel comfortable carrying the LCR with .357s hiking with your family, say if you had an encounter with a mountain lion or black bear?

    The LCR is for people who want a gun to shoot very little and not have to notice the weight at all. If you like to shoot and can afford it, buy a GP100 ( or comparable Smith) for home defense and target shooting, a 3″ SP101 or Model 60 for hiking, and a LCR for daily carry. But if you can only afford one $400 revolver to do everything , buy an SP101 in 2.25″ or 3″ – the shorter barrel if you want more concealability and the longer barrel if you want to occasionally carry concealed but also have more fun target shooting.

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

Back to top
mobile desktop