Chiappa Rhino Post of the Day: Norton, We Have a Problem

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmM-iF2-6IA

My first outing with the Chiappa Rhino was a glimpse into the future. My trip to the shooting quarry with the upside-down revolver felt like a trip in Marty McFly’s time-traveling DeLorean. It took me, briefly, to a future where magnum-caliber snubnoses kicked like rimfires and hit like field artillery. Reliability was perfect, accuracy was surprisingly good, and the only Biff in the ointment was a trigger so heavy that it would have felt at home on a caulking gun from Home Depot. So we complained . . .

Chiappa Prez Ron Norton took command of he situation. He upgraded the trigger and sent the gun back to TTAG for a follow-up review. The new trigger is much smoother than the notchy, stagey original, and much lighter. My gunsmith measured the DA pull at 8 pounds, and the SA pull at a very crisp 3 pounds, 8 ounces. I hopeed that the lighter, smoother trigger would let the Rhino deliver the practical accuracy it promised.

Unfortunately, the light trigger pull seems to come at the expense of very light primer strikes. With the exception of the first cylinder we fired (180 grain Winchester Black Talons, shown above), ignition was so poor that the Rhino could seldom fire three shots in a row without a misfire. Some primers had to be struck four times before they ignited, and other fired primers were struck so gently that only the slightest indentation was visible.

When a gun starts experiencing numerous misfires I immediately suspect the ammunition, but the 180-grain Black Talons fired flawlessly and accurately through my reference gun, a Smith & Wesson model 686 that left deep and convincing dents in all the Black Talon’s primers.

After confirming that the ammo was not at fault, we halted testing for safety reasons.  When a semi-automatic pistol misfires, I keep it pointed downrange for thirty seconds or so and then quickly eject the unfired round. This drill doesn’t work for a revolver, though. A misfired cartridge can be deadly (if it ignited belatedly) as long as it is confined in a firing chamber, and there’s no simple way to clear a revolver without pointing either the front or the back of the cylinder at some portion of your body.

So I’m shipping the Rhino back to Chiappa for more work. I hope it works better the next time I see it, and despite all of its teething problems, I really do want to see it again. If they can get it right, it can change everything we thought we knew about revolvers. If not, not.

comments

  1. avatar Ralph says:

    I hope they get it right, because the Rhino is pure gun porn.

  2. avatar RAH says:

    I own a Chiappa Rhino 200DS and fire it regularly. It has been a joy when it works. I have only a few issues since mine was replaced, yes replaced, under warranty. It still misfires rounds after about 900 rounds through the gun. Most of the problems are related to DA not single action.

    During its last repair, I mentioned the types of ammunition I was using, to the technicians and was told that i should try European ammunition as the American primers are more touchy. Is that even likely?

    I am wondering if the Rhino will be dependable enough for a carry gun in the future. Mine has been repaired 3 times before it was replaced and 3 since. Warranty service has had the gun as much as i have in the last year.

    Does anyone else have better results? Is it me or the design?

    RAH

    1. avatar Mark Umstead says:

      My Step Son just had to have one. Took it out to the range to sight it in. We had more misfires then fires. Were can we send this to have it fixed. It is just plain dangerous. He is disabled and his only protection gun. Thanks

  3. My .357 rhino 200d will only fire one(1) round of .357 and it jams. It will fire .38p all day. I have tried to contact chiappa four times,but have not had a return answer yet. Looks to me like they dont care about the coustomer,just the money!!

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

button to share on facebook
button to tweet
button to share via email